Macro trouble

I believe that it would eat it.

From what I have seen of your tank I don't think you can support a sea hare long term. You really don't have an abundance of algae. You could put the sea hare in your refugium after it cleans up the macro.
 
I would go with the seahare. ESPI is passing on Cruella's to me in a couple weeks, then I can pass it on to you.
 
Sounds good.
I may try a couple of emeralds in the meantime if I can get a couple locally.
 
Well, at least I learned a few things about this algae.

First, some pics

Heres another good pic...
3925Macro_Algae.jpg

"...It is brown with a faint bluish iridescence..."

If you got it and you got it from me (:rolleyes: )...GET IT OUT NOW!

Some quotes from various threads (note some of the authors):

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=6114744#post6114744 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Anthony Calfo
it is a scourge... will not easily wane into submission...
Few organisms will eat it. Dictyota also thrives in good water quality (hence the difficulty of starving it into submission)....Diadema urchins may help.

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=5421413#post5421413 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Anthony Calfo
its not only easily fragmented and distributed unwanted through the system... but its also rather noxious....I would not encourage Dictyota use in any significant measure for typical home aquaria.

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=4786787#post4786787 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by rshimek
It was probably on some rock you added, growing as a surface layer, perhaps only a couple cells thick. These algae don't have a "dormancy" period, it was likely just cropped low by something eating it. Any reef tank will have the nutrients necessary for a such an alga to thrive, coral reefs really are algal reefs with a thin layer of coral on them. If it is a problem in your system, and you don't have anything to control it, I would advise removing the rock it is on. Scraping the rock probably won't do it; many of these algae can regrow from a very small group of cells left o the rock.

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=3375139#post3375139 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Agu
Dictyota grows slowly but relentlessly. When you try to remove it pieces beak off and spread throughout your tank. Once established it's near impossible to remove manually, and it will overgrow your corals....I've tried an urchin but it was more interested in the coraline and barely put a dent in the dictyota. I finally was able to control it with a naso tang, but that was in a 180 with no other large fish. That's not an option for most people....IMO, get rid of it now !!
Agu

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=3375236#post3375236 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Bomber
.... small emeralds will eat it....As they get older and approach sexual maturity, they need more meat.
Also, smaller=younger=faster metabolism=growth

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=3375601#post3375601 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by gmh320
My tank was overrun with this stuff. It started out small and soon blossomed into a mess. Nothing would eat it, tangs, urchins, emerald grabs...until I got a Sea Hare..... if even the slightest bit is left in the tank it will keep growing and growing and growing.....

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=3154043#post3154043 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by R33f3r
The ONLY biological success I have had with dictyota is Dolabella seahares...Other than pruning it constantly, the sea hare will make quick work of it. I was losing the war until I bought one.

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=1846994#post1846994 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by kevinpo
The fish that have worked well for me in order of first one best:
Virigate Rabbit Fish
Naso Tang
Achilles Tang

HTH,
Kevin



Some potential consumers:

Blonde Naso Tang (most report Nasos love the stuff)
Red Sea Naso (is this the same fish?)
Emerald Crab (variable...hard to keep up with the growth)
Queen Conch (one report...fast eater)
Longspiny Urchin (may favor coraline (?) )
Sea Hare (Some reports positive, others not)

I can't believe that some people are offering it for sale/trade. Maybe a species-thing, but unless you know what you're getting, simply say "No Way"!



:mad2: :mad2: :mad2: :mad2: :mad2: :mad2:
 
Great........
Now you tell me, after it's quadrupled in size. :lol:

Last time I take a frag from you! hehe.
 
you could get a dremel tool with a flex shaft and a cut off wheel......... I think that is the closest you will get.

The key to kicking this alga's arse is to remove the stolon from the base that attaches to the rock, or else it can re-root and grow leaves again.

Some algae will look nice in your tank, but if it gets out of control, you inded will need to micro manage it like "Farmer Brown" chasing rabbits from his Brair patch.
 
Heres what I pulled out of my tank last nite....doesn't look like much, but took me a bit over 2 hours. :rolleyes: Only about 25-50% of what is in there. :mad2:
72023Dictyota-1-med.jpg


Close-up shot of some:
72023Dictyota-2-med.jpg
 
Did you see any pods pokin' around when you took it out?

I see that you're looking to get a bunch of emeralds to take care of some of that. I gotta give a strong warning against that. I just recently (couple months ago) had two emeralds eating the growth tips off my SPS. I thought it was just one of them, but I caught the second one doing it too. So be very careful adding them.
 
Yeah, I had an emerald in the past...he always liked to sit on top my M. cap. "waving" his claw. Never really caused any visable damage. I later decided to exile him. Don't really think that emeralds are the best choice in this case. As you can probably see, I'm getting desparate! I may end up getting a virgate rabbitfish.

Looking at my corals, you'd never know I had an algae problem. Maybe if I can get some coraline in there, that may compete for sites...I don't know. I'll try a few things in the meantime and see what effects I get as well as continue to remove what I can manually.

:rolleyes:
 
that looks alot like what dave papo had in his tank he said that a yellow tang he had would eat it. never saw it. but he did lots of water changes the last time he was active here. he would do 20% a week or more! in any case it stopped growing. i know they say it grows in any situation but maybe something else that the water changes did helped. just a thought. his was growing alot at a point. maybe you can pm him.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=7446867#post7446867 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by reefD
....but he did lots of water changes...he would do 20% a week or more!
Tried that route...no effect at all (maybe increased growth?). Need to change out my DI cartridge - its been a while (TDS still right around 0) - but who knows. Also got to switch out my actinic bulbs - don't think thats a problem, but then again... :rolleyes:

Just got to keep at it and hope something changes that proves less favorable for the algae.
 
Our nano reef suffers from the samething. We do a weekly 15% water change and has slowed its growth. Now have another form of it. Its more of a hard-hairy fern like plant. Does not grow long in length.

Problem i see with it is, How will the corals grow and spread if thats on the rock? Its nice rock but it may find its self in a Fuge!

Has lots of purples, pinks and red coraline on it.
 
You could always drain the tank, and let it "air dry" the algae.... that usualy kills it off after a few days.






* sarcasm .
 
Back
Top