Mantis & Seahorse

CoMMaNdeR

New member
Guys, maybe it is a stupid question, but does the mantis attacks a seahorse ? Can they be kept together in an aquarium?
 
Thank you,

I was not sure about it but thought that this will be the answer.

Another think guys, I have a 30g reef tank, about 4 months old, only with some leather.sp and zoanthid species and a 10g sump/refugium setup. I am still not sure what I am going to keep in it, but my choices are cuttlefish or seahorse.

I found 2 hippocampus reidi brilliant yellow, and I was going to buy them. They are tank raised and the LFS told me that they eat frozen mysis.

What is your opinion or suggestion guys?
 
Seahorses do best in tanks kept at about 72-74 degrees. Temps higher than this can result in higher chances of bacterial infections.

If you do decide to go with them, ask first to see them eat - I would make sure they actually are eating frozen.
 
The LFS said they are eating frozen mysis, he have totall 4 tank raised. I might see them eating first like you said.

On my 30g I have a metal halide of 150W, is it ok so much light for them?
 
The higher light should be okay, but I know that those lights can raise the temperatures of the tank, so that's what I would watch for.
 
The other thing is that the "tank raised" reidi seahorses are typically coming out of Asia where they are raised in net pens in the ocean, and are therefore exposed to the same sorts of problems (sometimes more) than wild caught. I would ask your LFS where they got them/who the breeder is. Last I checked, ORA wasn't even raising their reidi in-house and was importing them, so reidi is one of the species that I would especially recommend knowing exactly where they come from. Usually only possible by getting them from a private breeder or ordering directly from a reputable breeder like www.seahorsesource.com
 
Oh, duh, I ought to look at someone's location before I talk about sourcing species :p

I took a look at the site, and it looks like a wholesaler operation, not an aquaculturing facility. Are you sure they raise the seahorses themselves, and don't import them like they do the other fish species they provide?
 
To be honest I do not know if they have an aquaculturing facility or not, but when I asked them if their seahorses eat frozen food they assured me that they feed them frozen mysis.

I am going to try 2 reidi brilliant yellow, male & female and then I see along. Never kept seahorses, but in reef aquaria I have expeiance.

In their stocklist they have two different of yellow reidi,

- Hippocampus reidi yellow
- Hippocampus reidi brilliant yellow

What is the difference guys? The brilliant yellow is half price of the other yellow. I do not know why, maybe differenmt sizes or what?
 
No. They are just pricing based on color, which is silly, since seahorses can and do change color at will. Don't buy based on color.

As for eating frozen mysis, thats not what I'm worried about. If they're imported from the net pens in Asia, they'll have parasites, cilliates, and possibly really nasty bacterial isues that are expensive, if not impossible, to treat.
 
Thanks for your information ..

I will surely let you updated if I see any signs of ilness. What signs if they are visible should I notice if they have any parasites etc ?
 
Depends. Sometimes nothing. But symptoms could be any of the following:

*disinterest in food
*trying to eat but "missing" the food
*inability to get the food down/spitting out food
*"coughing"/flexing of the trigger
*itching/twitching
*not putting on weight even if they are eating
*white, stringy feces
*heavy breathing
*lesions, lumps, granulomas, white spots, bubbles, and other external manifestations of parasitic or bacterial infection
*whitening of the tail, whitening of the snout, erosion of the tail and/or snout
*erosion and/or fraying of the fins
*lethargy
*buoyancy issues (either sinking or floating)
*webbing of the skin/on the skin
*death, could be sudden and without warning

But, of course, some of these things could manifest later down the road. What I'd look for in the seahorses when you purchase them is having good size to them, no smaller than 3 inches, broad chests, filled out abdomens (space between body rings should not be concave), and high activity level, especially when feeding.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=14090415#post14090415 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by jcgso
DON'T DO IT!!! Your seahorse will be a great meal for the mantis if you do.

but my mantis never hurt my seahorse though.. it seems just ignore the seahorse, well, the mantis always stay alert when the seahorse get to close, but never attack it
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=14704562#post14704562 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by ridwan
but my mantis never hurt my seahorse though.. it seems just ignore the seahorse, well, the mantis always stay alert when the seahorse get to close, but never attack it

If this is a serious post and you are keeping a Mantis with seahorses then you have a disaster in the making for the poor horses.

The two should never be kept in the same tank. I hope you will remove the Mantis for the protection and safety of the seahorses.
 
Back
Top