Metal Toxins in LED Products

Megalodon

Clowning Around
I hope this isn't true ...

Metal Toxins in LED Products

David Gabel, ENN
February 11, 2011

LED lighting is the newest, most efficient form of lighting to hit the markets. It blows away even the most efficient compact fluorescent bulb, and is therefore, a much more expensive option. However, the benefits to the environment from LED's efficiency come with another environmental cost.

A new study from the University of California (UC) Irvine shows that LED bulbs contain lead, arsenic, and a dozen more potentially hazardous substances.

"LEDs are touted as the next generation of lighting. But as we try to find better products that do not deplete energy resources or contribute to global warming, we have to be vigilant about the toxicity hazards of those marketed as replacements," said Oladele Ogunseitan, chair of UC Irvine's Department of Population Health & Disease Prevention.

The researchers found that different LED bulbs contained different concentrations of toxins. For example, red bulbs, which can be found in vehicle brake lights or traffic lights, contain eight times more lead than what is allowed under California law. White bulbs had less lead, but contained more nickel. In general, higher intensity, bright bulbs had more toxic contaminants than lower intensity bulbs.

Many of the contaminants found in the LED bulbs have been showed to adversely affect human health. Toxins like lead and arsenic are linked to various cancers, brain damage, hypertension, skin rashes, and other illnesses. The copper in LED bulbs, once released, can affect rivers, lakes, and infect fish.

More @ http://www.enn.com/pollution/article/42345

Study @ http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/es101052q
 
It is true but if you handle them responsibly its not an issue.

BTW florescent bulbs, including compacts contain levels of mercury which complicates their disposal.
 
Can I hop on a soapbox for a PSA?

There is nothing special about LED's with respect to what elements they may or may not contain (as Bob pointed out above with fluorescent bulbs).

In our hobby, we use a lot of lighting, heaters, batteries and other electronic devices (all of which contain elements that are nasty when they accumulate anywhere). Fortunately, for us and our marine friends they are sealed and cannot cause harm unless that seal is broken.

When we are done with such devices, we must be sure to dispose of them properly (preferably not to a landfill or incinerator) to avoid contaminating the environment (and ourselves).

Just MHO
J
 
Compared to fluorescent , it is a considerably cleaner source. Add in useful life and efficiency, and it is really a moot point. I appreciate that they do these studies, but the spin that is put on them by those reporting is sometimes counterproductive. I did quite a bit of research in this area when working on a streetlighting LED retrofit proposal. The amount of 'toxins' per lumen per 50,000 hours is not even in the same ball park as most forms of lighting. The overall amount of resources used in the product is considerably less as well considering the bulk glass/metals in bulbs/ballasts etc. used in others. It may not be ideal, but it is definitely a move forward.
 
Compared to fluorescent , it is a considerably cleaner source. Add in useful life and efficiency, and it is really a moot point. I appreciate that they do these studies, but the spin that is put on them by those reporting is sometimes counterproductive. I did quite a bit of research in this area when working on a streetlighting LED retrofit proposal. The amount of 'toxins' per lumen per 50,000 hours is not even in the same ball park as most forms of lighting. The overall amount of resources used in the product is considerably less as well considering the bulk glass/metals in bulbs/ballasts etc. used in others. It may not be ideal, but it is definitely a move forward.

Good point.

Computers contain toxic heavy metals such as lead, cadmium, mercury and chromium, all carcinogenic.
 
The bad news: Yes the do contain the substances reported.
The good news: the cadmium free quantom dots are only about ten years out and they will be far superior to any LED fixture ever placed over a reef to date.
 
SERIOUSLY!....uuuuuuuuugh! I don't even pay attention anymore. Everything we do in every area of our lives is dangerous. I used to be concerned. I really tried. I did. Now here's what I do. I don't lick poison stuff. I wash my hands. Try not to eat any processed food. I don't lick stuff...lol...I used to lick everything. I used to lick my rock, my fishes, my coral and even my sand. Then I used to lick my lights and pumps and salt and heaters and sumps and skimmers and b ionic solutions and my chiller and GAC and GFO and my lmnop and ........well I could go on but it surfices to say I just don't lick stuff anymore.
 
All I know is that LEDs are made of plastic and the legs coming out will rust if you leave them in water. Not sure exactly what is inside, but pretty sure there are no chemicals, etc....
 
It's hermetically sealed, it shouldn't even matter that there's minute amount of heavy metals in LEDs. Just maybe a concern on disposal but other than that they should be safe to use the way they are intended, and eating them would be fine though I don't know why you would do it, and don't sue me if you do and start choking on it.
 
Eating LED's in California can cause cancer.....but only in California.....anywhere else they just cause heartburn.
 
All I know is that LEDs are made of plastic and the legs coming out will rust if you leave them in water. Not sure exactly what is inside, but pretty sure there are no chemicals, etc....

There is a little more to it then that :)

Given the small volume that exists inside the plastic case, one can come to the assumption that unless it's filled with uranium, it's unlikely to have an effect on a human, provided you're not eating them like PEZ or a bag of Lays chips.
 
Back
Top