Yes, all other fish appear fine. He finally let me take him out. I placed him in a quaranteen tank and he wasn't doing so good,so rather than what I thought was suffer, I froze him with liquid nitrogen,and placed him in my freezer. I'll take him to a fish vet I know and try and find out what caused this as I've researched for the last 2 days and really came up with nothing that matched. First fish death for me in almost 2 years of reefing, and he was my favorite,would always greet me first thing in morning and eat out of my hand. Man I gota check my depression med dosage because this death really hit me hard, I hate to watch anything suffer with a few exceptions. Thanks for the suggestions I'll keep you posted as to what I find from vet.