On the verge of a crash?

MJAnderson

Premium Member
I'm having some tank issues. First the setup

72g bowfront
29g sump
ASM g3 skimmer
Fish:
1 4" Kole Tang
1 3" coral beauty
2 2" Perc Clowns
1 2.5 Lawnmower blennie
1 small 6 line wrass
1 3" dottyback
2 2.5" Chromies

OK, my sad story. About a month ago I bought a bad batch of 20 snails. All died within a few days of putting them in my tank. Other snails started to die off (I didn't know it was just the new ones since they were the same kind) and I lost probably 40 snails in the last 4 weeks. Last week my frogspawn and one of my corals started looking a little unhappy. I tested all my parms (usually just Calc, alk and mag) and found that my nitrates were around 2.5-5and amonia registered, although below even the first mark. They had never registered before.

Anyway, my snails keep dieing, my corals continue to look unhappy (especially the 2 pociliporas and the frogspawn) but the fish look fine and other corals are colored up and growing.

Any thoughts? Besides stepping up the water changes (did 2 20% weekly changes instead of my usual 10%) should I be looking into something? Is my bioload too large or did the snail massacre a month ago start a cycle that my system can't handle? I haven't added any new fish in a while but they are getting bigger.

Thoughts? Things to look for?
 
problems

problems

Wow... sorry to hear about your carnage. I'm guessing you have plenty of live rock, plenty of flow, light, etc... I might be able to come over to take a look. I went to a friends house and ran about 12 tests. I found quite a few issues that don't seem like a big deal. However, when you consider all of them, it can start the dreaded downward spiral. I have 13 fish in my 125. However, the largest is a yellow tang. Sometimes I think I have too much bio load. I'm certainly at capacity. Bio load might be an issue. Flow might be a player and your dissolved Oxygen leves may be low.
 
I hate to say it but it sounds to me like its bioload related. Basically your biological filtration struggles to keep up and then starts to fall behind. A simple event like the death of a few snails could have put it over the top. 40 snails could definitely trigger another cycle. I would run the polyfilter just in case to make sure there are no heavy metals present. Although your skimmer should be more than sufficient, maximizing its efficiency will also help.
 
Back
Top