Thurge and psychodave, that gives me more hope about healing this guy.

I'm just so relieved that this is a common case, and not some weird situation that nobody can diagnose. Everybody's been very helpful with the situation, thank you.
I've taken out the margarita snails, so he would stop attempting to use his dactyl. Right now, he is able to bend and unbend one of the dactyls, but can't seem to smash so he just spins the snail around in his other hands.
Thanks to Stop & Shop seafood section, I've been able to get him variety of food today. Unfortunately, none of my LFS seems to carry Selco...so I might have to order online.
Here are some pictures of him eating his jumbo shrimps.

After I dropped it in, I realized that I should've chopped it up for him, but of course, he was already all over it. lol
Roy, I'm just wondering how you were able to tell that both of his dactyls were damaged? Of course, one of them is obviously damaged, but the other one he has no trouble bending/unbending...though he can't seem to use it. I'm just wondering what clues you saw in the picture that told you both were damaged.