Quarantine, to do, or not to do?

elady

New member
Hi folks,
All my fishes in reef were in quarantine before they entered to the aquarium.
I would like to stop with this method and enter the next new fishes with no quarantine
Who uses this method?
What do you think about it?

Best regards,
Elad
 
It's only going to take one fish with disease to topple the whole thing down... I would continue QT with all fish!!
 
Almost every problem that is discussed on the disease section of our forum could have been prevented by proper use of a QT. IMO, not using a QT is hard to imagine. I assume it worked, why change????
 
Last edited:
Why are you thinking of abandoning a successful strategy? I learned the hard way that the "throw them in and hope for the best" approach will eventually catch up with you.
 
Its a ticking time bomb to not QT any livestock (fish, corals, clams, etc). You may get lucky a few.or even a lot of times, bit it'll eventually catch up with you.
 
Hi,

Thanks for the replies:)
1. I wonder to stop with the quarantine because the Wrasses fishes.
2. My quarantine have no sand, for bottom suctioning.
The Wrasse doesn't like copper and no sand.
3. The weak fishes have no a chance for servival.
4. I do not quarantine corals.
 
You can QT without copper, simply observing the fish. Some people do use sand in Q-tanks for that very reason. The primary thing is to make sure the fish are healthy before adding them to the main tank.
As noted above, you only need to add one diseased fish to your tank to wipe out what you've done so far.
 
I have had one fish get very sick and die in my QT, after that I will never skip the QT with any fish. I have not been QTing my corals, but I do dip all my corals first, and the majority of my corals have come from other people's tanks, or large well establishedlfs tanks (the lfs I generally use has two 48 x 48 x 16 frag tanks).
 
Quarantine all fish. Use a container of sand in the tank for wrasses or other fish that need a sand bed.

As others have said, one sick fish can undo all the good you have so far. It is not worth the risk. If you get a diseased fish, you want to address the disease in the QT, plus you want your fish to be eating well before introduction to the other fish.
 
I've been in this hobby for a little over 10 years, never had a quarantine, never had a problem with disease either. However, I do wait to buy fish until they have been in the fish store for about 2 or 3 weeks checking on their habits.
 
I've been in this hobby for a little over 10 years, never had a quarantine, never had a problem with disease either. However, I do wait to buy fish until they have been in the fish store for about 2 or 3 weeks checking on their habits.

You've been very lucky.

Many, many years ago; I regularly drove home legally drunk after our office happy hour for many years. never had an accident. I'd sure never suggest anyone else do the same.
 
Last edited:
You've been very lucky.

Many, many years ago; I regularly drove home legally drunk after our office happy hour for many years. never had an accident. I'd sure never suggest anyone else do the same.

:lolspin:
The best example i ever heard
 
You've been very lucky.

Many, many years ago; I regularly drove home legally drunk after our office happy hour for many years. never had an accident. I'd sure never suggest anyone else do the same.

FTW.

I am totally stealing this. Very good point.
 
Hi,

My quarantine tank is Jebo R331 (22L), i wonder if it too small?
I'm afraid to damage the fish in this small quarantine instead benefit.
I have no place for bigger quarantine.
do i still keep using quarantine?

Best regards,
Elad
 
Back
Top