Recommend pump for water changes

Mr.Mcgibblets

New member
I just purchased a RODI unit for my garage and I would like to pump from a trash can to the tank via a garden hose. I was looking at a mag drive 12 for this purpose but they are rather expensive. Can anyone recommend a cheaper submersible pump? I saw a little giant pump but it is oil cooled and I was worried about it leaking.
 
Funny you mention cheaper as i would recommend a Mag myself. Try looking for them used either on here or craigslist. Otherwise i can see quiet one's or the maxi-jet utility pumps working also. Hope that helps, Wiz ;)
 
i use a maxi jet 1200, its a little slow but works well for water changes. i stepped it off just now and its 50 heal to toe steps of my size 11 shoes plus the verical lift of the storage barrel and the stand/tank
 
I put wheels under my Brute can and place it right beside the tank. I use a ViaAqua 1800 (about $25) and with 44" of lift it will shoot a stream out of the 3/4" ID hose almost across a 30" tank.
 
Harbor freight has some cheap pumps, I would be worried about cleaning them though, everything in that store stinks.
 
You could probably be happy with anything more than 400-500 gph. Check the classifieds here and Craiglist for a used Mag or QuietOne.
 
I just measured looks like I have a 50 ft horizontal and about 5 vertical run from can to tank. I used the head loss calculator and with a mag 9.5 it is showing 567 gph flow. Does that sound about right? If so that sounds like an acceptable flow rate for a 40g water change.
 
I use a Mag 7, it's also a spare for the one in my sump. I've bought all of my Mag pumps used.

By the way, don't use a garden hose unless it's rated for potable water.

Jeff
 
I have the same scenario - brut in the garage, pump through a garden hose about 20-30 ft to my tank. I use a pond pump I got at home depot.. sorry don't recall the exact one, I'd have to look when I get home. I did cut the metal ends off the garden hose though, and the pump has a hose barb that fits it perfectly built right in.
 
Where is the tank in relationship to the garage? Need to know how much head pressure the pump is going to see before being able to recommend one. If the tank is upstairs there is no way an MJ1200 will work.
 
No kidding, my MJ1200 barely flows from the floor to the top of my 90g tank.

Todd, he said he has 50' horizontal & 5' vertical.
 
Errrr just picked up a via aqua 8000 on sale then spent 30 minutes at Home Depot trying to find a fitting to connect the pump to a hose and had no luck. The only solution I could find a food grade vinyl hose that would have cost me 150 dollars:eek2: I guess I will have to exchange for a smaller pump unless anyone knows of another way??
 
Alrighty, got home and just looked. I have 2 of these pumps, one of them I took a regular garden hose (make sure it is not treated with any kind of anti-bacterial or other stuff) and cut the brass fittings off both ends. Then I used a stainless steel hose clamp to attach it to the barbed fitting. The pump with the clamp does not sit in the water full time, I take it out when I'm not using it.

These two pumps have been running good for me for a few years now. I'm only pumping the water maybe 30' or so, but it does have to pump it up and into my display at times, which is pretty close to 6' vertical.

Versa Gold Series g535:
http://www.macarthurwatergardens.com/beckett-water-gardening/beckett-G535-versa-gold-pump.shtml

I don't recall paying that much for them, but I'm pretty sure I got them at home depot. like I say, it's been a long time. ;)
 
Yup, the pump does have a stainless steel shaft on the impeller. I've only had them for a few years, and when I checked the model early tonight I took a close look for rust. Didn't see any noticeable rust, but who knows it might be an issue some day. I definitely would not recommend them as a return pump, or anything else that's going to see full time duty or be part of a critical system in the tanks operation.

Like I said, when they do come in contact with saltwater it isn't for long, and I don't leave it sitting in there. My pumps are most often just in plain RO water.

With regard to the hose.. I hate to quote myself, but "I took a regular garden hose (make sure it is not treated with any kind of anti-bacterial or other stuff) and cut the brass fittings off both ends."

I reckon with the hose it's the same scenario as the pumps. They're not in constant contact with the tank water, and they do get drained out and coiled up when I finish the water change. I wouldn't recommend a garden hose as a permanent fixture in the tank - mostly because I'm not sure how the rubber would hold up under constant use over time. For just doing water changes though, it's been working fine for several years.
 
It's not the ends of the garden hose that are an issue, it's the material the hose is made of.

Jeff

Not all garden hoses are appropriate for the transfer of saltwater. It has to be approved for potable water. Another alternative is Pex . Typically it'll be smaller diameter but you'll know it's made with inert substances.
 
Back
Top