Red Sea Refractometer Problems - Help needed.

afm32607

Member
Just bought a Red Sea refractometer. Seems like the worst investment ever. It will not hold calibration between tests most times, and I don't mean the following day. I mean it looses calibration between the time I calibrate it to when I test the water and then check the calibration fluid. I calibrate, test tank water, and then test calibration fluid and the refractomter is off by a few PPT in one direction or another, different each time. I am not sure if this is just a faulty unit but that seems outrageous. I cannot trust any result it gives me.

I have even calibrated it to the standard solution and then checked it on RO/DI water and then when retesting the calibration fluid I received different results. Further I have double checked this with a cheap BRS or amazon unit that I borrowed and confirmed the poor results. When calibrated using RO/DI fluid the unit tests out at 0 ppt. However, when I then go and look at the calibration fluid it reads between 30 and 33 ppt. Yes I dry off the refractometer lens between tests. I am at a loss for what to do other than throw it away.

The ambient temperature is high 60s and the same light source is used for all tests. While I realize temperature plays a role in accuracy it should not, when kept constant, impact the precision of the units.

I used to have a really cheap one that I used for years until I knocked it off a table onto the concrete floor. I'm hoping it is my testing method or that the particular unit is defective. Does anyone else have this problem with Red Sea's refractometer? Any suggestions?
 
I have the same issue with the Red Sea refractometer holding calibration. What seems to help for me, at least short term, is if I cycle the calibration screw up and down the full range when calibrating.
 
Unfortunately, they're notorious for losing calibration. My Red Sea is on my shelf collecting dust, and I bought a new one off the classifieds here, which I believe came from BRS. It sucks, especially due to the price, but I would buy a BRS one which is $40. If you really want to splurge and have a salinity tool that will last you forever, get the digital milwaukee one. It's about $100 new, but you can probably get a used one for 70-80.
 
Everyone seems to have the same issue with the red-sea one.

If you really want to splurge and have a salinity tool that will last you forever, get the digital milwaukee one. It's about $100 new, but you can probably get a used one for 70-80.

Unless your eyesight requires it I would stick to an ATC refractometer for a third the cost. It is more accurate.

0 to 50 PSU, +/-2 PSU Accuracy
 
I looked into the electric meters. They're inaccurate enough that it would cause me some stress. I guess I'll just have to find another brand. Too bad cause I just bought this one. If anyone wants to deal with its problems I will sell it for $20 plus shipping haha.
 
Back
Top