I've been seriously considering a Red Sea reefer tank, but ever since I saw a Waterbox at my LFS I've been all but sold. For my purposes, I really like the shallow 12" depth which WB offers and they look very well built. I haven't picked one up yet because I'm hoping to find one on the used market eventually.
But as to your original question, if a guy has the means to pick up a Red Sea tank, I don't think he'd be disappointed. This is not based on personal experience, just from fondling one at my LFS and from the last few months of research I've done.