Reefing on a budget: where to concentrate the cash

Sk8r

Staff member
RC Mod
For my money, it's the tank itself: all the size you can manage for the space you have to put it in, whatever that be. And a sump, which doesn't HAVE to have partitions, but in the case a fish gets down there, they're a good idea---and if you ever want a fuge, partitions are a must---or you have weed in your pump: not good.

The diy-skilled can drill, buy a downflow box, (a leak/water accident preventer that goes into your tank) ---or you can buy tanks that have them. In trying NOT to spend money, you CAN use a hang-on downflow box, but if you have any accessibility issues reaching the U tubes and restarting them, it's going to be a headache. I've used the hang-ons for freshwater, and swore at them a great deal. WIth a builtin downflow, you never ever have to restart suction.

What not to get is a canister filter---in terms of potential for accidents to your floor---and in terms of running a reef. They're fine for fish-onlies, particularly if you have messy eaters, but for a reef, they're going to have 'ups and downs' in nitrate---you clean it, it's down, you don't clean it, it rises---and corals don't like nitrate above 5 almost as badly as fish don't like ammonia. They can also cause a disaster: we have a freshwater tank that was on one, and a seal failed---yeah. A micro-marine tank can run safely on a couple of high-end Penguin filters. Not great---but basic critters can survive fine with that.

With a sump you have a place for ugly equipment, a place for a skimmer (see below: fixes nitrate problem) and reactor (removes phosphate which fuels algae) and so on. And you have a place to add chemicals and to run a water change without disturbing your fish. (10% a week change keeps your trace elements up.)

The other place to sink money is your lights: you have to consider lighting if you want a reef. Softies don't take as strong a light as stonies in general, but light is literally what they eat, the way flowers need sunlight: their internal flora take in light and produce sugars which go directly into the tissues of the corals. Wrong light, no corals. Fish don't care about your lights and may actually hide during the brightest phase of the reef lighting.

Heaters: get the absolute best---a cheap one can burn your house down, no kidding. And don't take used.

Tests: for fish only, you should buy a numerical-result alkalinity test (I use Salifert); and a refractometer (salinity). For stony reefs, you also need a numerical test for calcium and one for magnesium. You will be dosing buffer to keep the alk up; and dosing calcium and magnesium to sustain a stony reef's skeleton-building.

Dosers: a plastic measuring spoon and a cup to premix the dose in.
A little logbook to track your tests: you dose to TRENDS, not to disasters. So you watch the movement of the test numbers, and head them off before they become bad.

Sand and rock---you can start with aragonite sand and nearly all dry limestone, but condition your rock in saltwater. WE have a sticky on that. Read it. If you skip this step, you will be hip-deep in algae.

A ro/di unit, 4 cylinder recommended. This turns your mineral-laden tapwater into zero-mineral water, ready to take the precise mineral balance of your salt mix, and NOT give you fields of waving green algae or worse.

If your lights don't have a built-in timer, timers from the hardware store.

A skimmer--if you turn out to battle nitrate, your answer is to spend some money on this item, which needs a sump to live in.

A stand: you can use anything that can bear the weight, but fish-stands are calculated to stand the strain. You need sump access. You've got to be able to clean the skimmer.

Do you need a controller? I learned to run without one, and never have gotten around to having one. They are an expense you can spare until you decide you need one. I dose calcium via a simple addition of kalk (calcium compound) powder into my topoff water, while maintaining my alk and mag at specific levels, dead easy to do.

You need a stack of old towels, a couple of buckets (or Brute trashcans depending on size of your rig).

You can buy anything used EXCEPT a heater. Just shop around and look at some functioning systems or for-sale systems until you know what you're looking at, and won't be sold an antique.

Best during the 'buying' phase,---join a reef club: we have a long list of them by region and city. Members may have tanks to sell, skimmers they've outgrown, and ADVICE---these are the people who can tell you whether that tank offered for sale is a good deal or not. Ask questions. Always ask questions.
 
One good and cheap save-your-tank item is a Penn-plax battery-driven airpump. In a power out, you can keep that bubbler going so long as you have batteries to feed it. Available at big box pet stores. As a rule of thumb, most tanks can go 8 hours in a power-out with no circulation, but beyond that, bad things start to happen.

And when you're starting down the "I need more circulation!" road, consider that my 50 gallon tank could easily take a (measured from a pump in the under-stand) 950 gallons per hour (gph) flow, but corals don't appreciate being blasted, either. These fish and corals are used to the surge of the ocean, and that turnover does help oxygenation, as does your skimmer. Powerheads and wavemakers agitate the surface to help bad gasses leave the tank. But it's easy to get one powerhead and another powerhead, and spend a lot of money inching your way toward a good flow when maybe there was a better solution. Figure how much water movement you need at all levels, including the bottom layer of your tank, and buy once and right---rather than ending up with multiple purchases that don't quite solve the problem. Ask. Consult. That's the value RC can be to you: you'll get varied answers out of varied experience, but the size and shape and depth of your tank are highly relevant to what you need for water movement. LPS tentacles should wave gently, and there should be no pockets of grunge on the sand. Again, ask advice: multiple powerheads pointed in various directions may indeed solve one situation, and for another, you may need another kind of flow-boost entirely. Ask around, not just of one source trying to sell you an item.
 
Last edited:
An ATO for both your main system and your qt, something easy to sterilize. I'm currently using a Hydor with good results, a little too forgiving (about a half-inch drop before it reacts) but on my system that's not a big salinity change.
 
And closely related to what you intend to keep. THAT is one of the first of all questions to resolve. Wandering from one idea to the other is a way to lose specimens and money, having to rebuy equipment, etc. There are broad classes of fishes and corals, there are size requirements, lighting requirements. Best thing to do before you buy a thing is to get some idea what you want to keep, get with a reef club---their help can be huge---and get a direction for your project. Bear in mind, ambitions for a whale shark on a 30 gallon budget are doomed. Sometimes you can't have what you want, and remember that sellers' estimates of a fish's adequate swimming room will favor the store; but the fish's actual comfort and welfare may take a little more than that. The average size for a great number of fishes is 3-5 inches. Another large group come in the 10" size range; and then there are those that get bigger than that. Habits matter: browsers versus speed racers. So ask us!!!! been there, got many teeshirts, and willing to help.
 
Lighting will be your biggest decision imho, I'd research that first,

I don't see lighting being a big issue if you are on a budget. Even most inexpensive fixtures, like the sub $100 MarsAqua will grow healthy coral.

However, if you mean the big field of choice between T5, MH or led. Yes, there is a decision to be made, but it's not as much about the budget as it is about the form. IMHO, led fixtures have come down so much in cost and even the basic ones offer things that inexpensive t5 and MH can't, it's becoming an easier and easier decision all the time.

The cost goes up for lights based on how many human features you want (built-in timers, sunrise/sunset control, multiple channel color control, wifi, Apex compatibility...). None of these are necessary if you are working on a budget. None of these extra cost features make the actual light better for the coral or fish.
 
I don't see lighting being a big issue if you are on a budget. Even most inexpensive fixtures, like the sub $100 MarsAqua will grow healthy coral.

However, if you mean the big field of choice between T5, MH or led. Yes, there is a decision to be made, but it's not as much about the budget as it is about the form. IMHO, led fixtures have come down so much in cost and even the basic ones offer things that inexpensive t5 and MH can't, it's becoming an easier and easier decision all the time.

The cost goes up for lights based on how many human features you want (built-in timers, sunrise/sunset control, multiple channel color control, wifi, Apex compatibility...). None of these are necessary if you are working on a budget. None of these extra cost features make the actual light better for the coral or fish.
That is true. If people are going to spend wisely, lighting is the easiest place to waste money. Don't get a 30$ light, or a 1000$ one if you are on a budget.

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk
 
The whole lighting field has undergone a huge change since 2007. And older units are not necessarily a bad second-hand buy. MH kits that cost 800.00 new are being sold very cheap, and your greater expense is replacing bulbs every 6-8 months. THOSE haven't gotten cheaper.
 
The whole lighting field has undergone a huge change since 2007. And older units are not necessarily a bad second-hand buy. MH kits that cost 800.00 new are being sold very cheap, and your greater expense is replacing bulbs every 6-8 months. THOSE haven't gotten cheaper.

Ha! You can buy a MarsAqua led fixture that will work for at least 5 years for roughly the cost of one good MH bulb!
 
I'll say my MH rig was good---it's been a headache getting the LED right, but it's getting there.
 
Back
Top