mmmmsushi
New member
GS,
While what you said I guess logically makes sense, I wouldn't bank on that. Quarantine tanks frequently have few hiding places and often are not good places to reduce stress. As you pointed out they are ideal for battling infections and such because you can dose the water. Basically a quarantine process is for keeping the new member seperate from your display until you are sure it is healthy or cure any disease it may have. It is not for settling in, in the sense of reducing stress from surroundings.
We also know that some species of fish just don't handle the transition from the ocean to captivity well. The regal angel being one of them. I just don't want people to think that if they properly quarantine a regal it will negate all the previous experiences people have had where they lost the fish.
For your info, I did NOT quarantine my Regal. I did a drip for a long while and when the temperature, PH and salinity were the same I dropped her in. She did get some lymphocystis, but now she is doing great. In the store she was showing signs of Ich, but after a week of medicine at the LFS I brought her home. My thought was that it would be less stress with her in a 120g rather than a 20g Q tank.
While what you said I guess logically makes sense, I wouldn't bank on that. Quarantine tanks frequently have few hiding places and often are not good places to reduce stress. As you pointed out they are ideal for battling infections and such because you can dose the water. Basically a quarantine process is for keeping the new member seperate from your display until you are sure it is healthy or cure any disease it may have. It is not for settling in, in the sense of reducing stress from surroundings.
We also know that some species of fish just don't handle the transition from the ocean to captivity well. The regal angel being one of them. I just don't want people to think that if they properly quarantine a regal it will negate all the previous experiences people have had where they lost the fish.
For your info, I did NOT quarantine my Regal. I did a drip for a long while and when the temperature, PH and salinity were the same I dropped her in. She did get some lymphocystis, but now she is doing great. In the store she was showing signs of Ich, but after a week of medicine at the LFS I brought her home. My thought was that it would be less stress with her in a 120g rather than a 20g Q tank.