Rock Structure Poll

[wazupjames]

Structure A:

Structure B:

Keep in mind that the structure on the right side is still going to get small pieces on the bottom to taper off in both scenarios.

A or B? Comments?

 

[Korrine]

I like B better.

 

[username in use]

Id like to see a "C"

 

[snorvich]

Well, I like them both. If I HAD to only choose one, I would go with "B"

 

[wazupjames]

Id like to see a "C"

So you dont like a or b?

 

[wedwards]

I like "B"

 

[Ranchero]

I like B
Nice rock by the way

 

[RVANANO]

I like B best but I think you should keep at it.

 

[Forensicdude]

neither. looks too "moundy"

 

[willy7499]

I like "B" better. It does look like you may need a little more rock though as it has a delicate appearance to me.

I have a related question though. How would you keep the rock in this formation? I did mine with Aquamend and it didn't work well.

 

[wazupjames]

Aquamend and Superglue has always worked very well for me. As it sits it is very sturdy I can shake the tank around and nothing moves but I would glue a few parts.

 

[blennielove]

I like B also.
Question...if someone said "I like A", how do you go back to A?
I've done very small tanks (6 gallon nanos) with a total of 10 pieces of rock and couldn't put it back in the same way...

 

[wazupjames]

Lol, I wrote down which rock I moved to where. For the most part it is added rock not moved rock. I know what you mean though I did the same thing once with a 28 gallon and was so irritated for about 3 hours trying to get the rock back to the way it was.

 

[aleonn]

I like "B" as it'll provide some cool arches for the fish to swim through

 

[n0rk]

What're you keeping? Depending on what you've got intended for it will make a lot of difference to what works.

 

[sandman111]

I like b.. I like caves...the bigger the better.

 

[wazupjames]

What're you keeping? Depending on what you've got intended for it will make a lot of difference to what works.

Mostly Soft corals some SPS.

 

[RyanAlan]

I was able to attend a rockscaping presentation by a professional and it really opened my mind up.

One of the points that he mentioned was following "the golden rule". I can't quote some of points that he made but you can review this link that I found as it outlines it in good detail.

http://www.leonardosreef.com/guide-to-iwagumi/

When you see this in action in an aquarium you will understand how amazing these points make sense to the human eye.

Good luck!

 

[Semillon]

Both look terrible, change it now before its too late!

 

[Lukey]

The guy above me speak truth. They are both pretty average.

Another vote for C here.