Rocks/Sand Are clumping together and becoming solid

demariners

Work In Progress
Not sure why but I noticed that my substrate is becoming clumped and even solid at the bottom that I can not even run my hands through it. Any ideas what is causing this and how to fix it. Thank you.
 
The things that usually cause sand clumping are:

1. new sand/aquarium
2. High pH, usually from limewater (kalkwasser)
3. excessive calcium and alkalinity, and perhaps low magnesium


The clumping may be direct precipitation of calcium carbonate between grains, or it may be a bacterially driven process.
 
The tank is about a year old or so. Eitherway I do use kalkwasser and my pH is now stable between 8.2-8.4. I check calcium and alk weekly and they are pretty good at 400 ppm/9 dkh and mag is usually between 1250-1400. How can I fix this? Should I do a calcium reactor instead of kalkwasser?
 
Personaly, I got this problem when I was dosing Kalk at above than ph 8,25. I adjusted my controller to avoid this and the problem is solved.
 
In the case of a new tank's sand clumping does that go away with time? I always thought it was because of ammonia and nitrite eating bacteria.
 
The tank is about a year old or so. Eitherway I do use kalkwasser and my pH is now stable between 8.2-8.4. I check calcium and alk weekly and they are pretty good at 400 ppm/9 dkh and mag is usually between 1250-1400. How can I fix this? Should I do a calcium reactor instead of kalkwasser?

A two part could be a reasonable alternative, as is a CaCO3/CO2 reactor, but few people stop limewater for this reason. I use it without such issues, except when I first set up the tank.
 
Well I have been able to stabilize my ph at about 8.2-8.3 daily now. So I am hoping this will be the fix. I was going to remove all the solid pieces and replace them but I wanted to make sure this will not happen again. I am hoping the clumps break away on their own. I really am not sure a calcium reactor would be a fix for me due to the price and the need for one. I only have a couple clams and anemones.
 
I had this same issue without dosing kalkwasser, only using a calcium reactor. I too noticed it at about the 1 yr mark.

He clumps turned into the perfect substrate for Valonia, so I ended up removing all the substrate when I moved the tank.
 
Back
Top