Seahorse compatibility questions

Fishmaster13

New member
I have been considering purchasing a couple of seahorses lately. What I was originally hoping to do is plop them into my 90 gallon reef tank (1 year old). Then I did some research... It doesn't seem like the best idea. It looks like I might just have to get a separate species tank for them, but I'm asking if it would be possible to add them to my reef tank since I already have 3 tanks running and 6 other cages for various animals. In my reef tank I currently have snowflake clownfish, a firefish, a mandarin, and a blue striped pipefish. I had an impulse buy with the pipefish a couple of months ago but it's done great in the tank. I was considering getting a fairy wrasse but I would hold back if I were to add seahorses to the tank to prevent compitition. The clown is a little pesky but I'm not to worried about his competition. Then for the corals. This is the part that concerns me. I have tons of polyps and other nonaggressive to moderately/mostly nonaggressive corals. My concern is that while I don't have any anemones, I do have 2 frogspans and 2 hammer corals, all medium size. I have read mixed reviews, but the general outcome advises against it. If they aren't a huge problem, however, I would try my luck with the seahorses. I can lower the temperature gradually down from 78° to 76° easily and my flow is fine for them already. My CC is just snails and small hermits with a couple shrimp. I was leaning towards H. Reidi but if anyone has suggestions for different species that are possibly less likely to get stung it would be greatly appreciated. Sorry this was so long but I wanted to give the details. If you made it all the way down here congrats. Thanks for any help!
 
Oh ya one more thing I forgot to mention is that I have a very established copepepod population in the tank and have a couple feather dusters as well
 
I'd go further and say the odds are you don't get past 6 months even without serious problems.
Unfortunately it's not the keeper that suffers, it's the seahorses.
 
Looks like I'll probably have to get a species tank, but my last question is that I've heard from a couple sources that certain seahorse species are more adapted to avoiding getting stung. Is this true? I doubt it but I suppose it could be possible. I heard those species are H. Comes and H. and H. Barboura. Is that possible? I'm flexible on the seahorse species if any could somehow manage to work in my reef tank.
 
Well I've been a member here since 99, and a member on seahorse.org since 2002, and I've never seen any documentation saying any species is more likely to avoid getting stung.
All you can do is to select corals and other livestock that can survive the lower recommended temperatures of 68° to 74°F, and are suited to lower light conditions than many reefs are kept at, and, that don't sting.
SEE HERE FOR TANKMATES GUIDE
 
Thanks raygay, I'm doing the right thing and getting a seahorse species tank. Everyone can ignore this thread now, thanks for the help everyone who replied. I posted a bunch of new questions above:lmao:
 
Well I've been a member here since 99, and a member on seahorse.org since 2002, and I've never seen any documentation saying any species is more likely to avoid getting stung.
All you can do is to select corals and other livestock that can survive the lower recommended temperatures of 68° to 74°F, and are suited to lower light conditions than many reefs are kept at, and, that don't sting.
SEE HERE FOR TANKMATES GUIDE

Excellent resource, thanks!!!
 
IME with trying clowns, they do not work longterm either. I wish they would have, but they don't.

Barbouri are often found living in the reefs, but that does not make them immune to a sting.

Hammer and Euphillia corals are out, but there are many other species of corals and fish that can live with seahorses without problems. I actually like to have some working fish in with seahorses. Ones that like to clean the left over food, especially off of the sand.

IME there are many many species of fish that do just fine with seahorses.

JME
 
Back
Top