Use a multi-meter (voltage tester) instead of yourself.
You mentioned you unplugged JUST ABOUT EVERYTHING so that means you did not unplug whatever it was that is leaking voltage into your water. Keep unplugging stuff until you find whatever is leaking. Heaters are common culprits but it could be a powerhead, pump, lights, etc.
Also, its good practice to have your electrical outlets that you tank is plugged into, GFCI protected. If not, replace your outlet or you can buy GFCI protected surge protectors/multi outlet strips. This will not fix your problem but could save your life in the event of the electricity finding a good ground.