Sunlit large reef.. how hot?

sfsuphysics

Active member
Since this topic went away really quick off the radar in the lighting section, I thought I'd ask some of you who actually have large reefs and sunlight as a good source off light, how hot do your tanks get? Do you use any sort of cooling method? Fans? chiller? Eh?

Also curious about more "sane" large tanks... not ones with 4 decimals worth of gallons! :D
 
Might have gotten accidentally erased, I seem to recall some forum update/mumbo jumbo around the time I posted my thread.

Eitherway bravo on the link, I'll be reading it happily, thank you.
 
That thread is on here too. Its the "how I spent my daugthers inheritence" thread. Awesome thread though none the less.
 
There are several good natural sunlight threads just search for solar tubes in some of the forums. I read one a while back about some guy out in Arizona that had a very nice looking sun lit tank.
 
I have read some of the threads on here with sunlit tanks, especially that guy in Portugal who has a really awesome display... however one thing that I don't see many deal with (or at least mention much) is the rise in temperature due to Sunlight striking down on it (lots of solar energy). There are always other aspects with temperature that they deal with (hot climate, etc) and they deal indirectly with the sunlight via that.
 
No heat transfer? Why not? You're shining light into the tank. What would be different than sunlight without solatubes? Only thing I could think of is that IR light somehow is being absorbed by the tubes, of course IIRC water interacts with microwaves more so than other wavelengths.
 
So how much light does your solartubes actually put on your tank? I'm looking to sunlight being the primary lighting method, with some t5s as supplimental lighting for when the sun isn't shining on my back porch anymore, Looking at your tank you have more from MH lights than you do from solatubes.

Also do these tubes have to be a straight shot? Or can they make a dogleg bend?
 
I do have more MH's than a true solatube tank. I could say my tank is a hybrid. I only get direct sunlight on the tubes for 3-4 hours a day because I don't have all day southern exposure on that side of the house. Plus I live on Long Island NY so it's not too sunny here all year long. If I were in AZ or FL I would of put 4 21" tubes with actinic lighting and remove the diffusers from the tubes.

I kind of did my tank to try to replicate as much of nature as possible. I do get a natural wakeup cycle even without direct sunlight in the morning and the fish love it. I don't have many corals (the tank is still very young) but the few I have also open up nicely without direct sunlight ion the morning.

How much light do you get in your tank area a day? Also do you think you have enough lighting hours all year long? If you get a significant drop-off of daylight in the winter like I do here on LI you may not be able to support a tank with solatubes alone. I assume in CA you do get enough light but I honestly don’t know enough.

Vic
 
Well, I live in San Francisco, so the sunlight here is shaky at best (A quantum flux meter is really a desirable purchase though so I can see how much light a cloudy day really provides).

On any particular sun day though light would hit the "tank" (future place of it that is) from about sunrise to 3-4 depending upon the time of year. However it's on the south side of the house so it would be all the time. I did anticipate using some sort of supplemental lighting though.

The whole reason of using direct light through UV block plexi/fiberglass is that the sun would come from different angles throughout the day so any sort of supplemental lighting can fit over the tank and not take away "valuable lighting real-estate", which unfortunately the solatubes would.

The overall idea was to build a top-down/side view tank, very similar to an outdoor one I saw at the Maui Ocean Center, however inside my porch so pollutants would be minimized (and any sort of rainwater), also some exotic ideas are floating around, like cutting a hole in the side of the house and having an indoor/outdoor tank ... but don't want to dwell too much on what I MIGHT be doing down the road.

Now my experience (all one of them :D) with a glass tank on a south facing window was really bad, the temperature got really hot over the course of the day 90°F, but the tank was only 38 gallons, so I was wondering how/if that heating scaled up with size, and if that were the case what cooling methods would I need to use. Sometime this summer I might be experimenting with a 300g rubbermaid tub just to try and gauge how the temperature would fluctuate during what would be the "hottest" time of the year.
 
Back
Top