In all fairness, not all corals will look the same in everyone's tank. There's also multiple species of "superman monti" that I've seen, with a very similar color pattern but obviously different growth pattern.
I've got a 5" potential SM monti coming later this week...kind of grayish-blue with orange-red polyps, but I expect it to color up into something nicer, even if it's not a true blue/red SM monti.