There is a weird rumor going around about coral-banded shrimp...

Sk8r

Staff member
RC Mod
They do NOT pair with watchman gobies. They are predators that may eat small fish. They are somewhat dangerous to have in a tank where you have any fish under 5". The watchman partner is the tiger pistol. But that deserves a caution, too, since tiger pistols kill firefish and other small fishes that may burrow or seek a burrow for sleep.
 
That is a rumor? I thought everyone knew the CBS's are dangerous to small fish...

You would think, but there are still threads about it. And half the time the advice about the dangers of those shrimp falls on deaf ears.
 
Now you said watchmen gobies and tiger shrimp... what about other species of gobies? Do they all prefer tiger shrimp as well? Just curious, as I was looking at a red banded shrimp, Alpheus randalli, on Live Aquaria and they were saying Alpheus randalli will pair with shrimp gobies.

Looking for some more clarification since a nano means I can't get the symbiotic relationship of clown and anemone easily, so I'm interested in the shrimp/gobie duo.
 
I've had one of the buggers draw blood on my finger when I was trying to move them with my hand.

They have strong nippers !!!
 
I do agree with the "so called" rumor, but those CBS get a bad rap IMO. If you ever get a chance, let the CBS adjust the vice on your finger... A healthy fish should have NO problem avoiding that IMHO.
 
I have a pair of CBS and now I know why I can never keep a YWG. I knew CBS were opportunistic feeders but assumed they only went for fish that were sick or weak. Always learning something new.

BTW, I have a bi-color gobie and it has done well in the tank. Just luck or are the YWG only ones prone to this demise?
 
I do agree with the "so called" rumor, but those CBS get a bad rap IMO. If you ever get a chance, let the CBS adjust the vice on your finger... A healthy fish should have NO problem avoiding that IMHO.

That has not been my experience. Never again for me.
 
not little clowns. Don't trust them.

Re alphaeus randalli, that is the candy cane pistol shrimp. They're calling it red banded in the ad, and now I see where some of this craziness is starting. There is a huge and dangerous difference between stenopus hispidus (coral banded) and alphaeus randalli (candy cane). For those of you unfamiliar with the Latin scientific names of specimens, here's the skinny: if the first names given aren't identical, they're NOT close. You'll find alphaeus bellulus (tiger pistol), etc, and all the alphaeus guys are pistols. The stenopus clan aren't: they include stenopus hispidus (coral banded), stenopus scutatellus (golden Caribbean boxing), stenopus tenuirostris (blue boxing), etc, etc, and are generally called 'boxing' shrimp because of their wide-armed, pugnacious and dangerous come-on.

So when in doubt, google the Latin name: that will give you pictures, that will give you habits of the family cousins, etc, and that will give you a good idea of whether you want to invite this clan into your tank, and what the downsides may be.
 
Man I have a huge one in my tank and lived with 2 firefish, 2 smaller clowns, small goby, springers dotty, and never had any issues at all! I'm learning some crazy new stuff.
 
:lol: Mandragen, you have some very canny fish, I'll say, or a rock arrangement that never makes your fish go through a narrow spot (which is often where ambushes happen)---

Some situations seem to go on for a while and then all of a sudden there's a problem, just as angels can be fine in a reef for a year, until one morning when the moonphase or the stars are right, they take a sample, figure it out, and immediately chow down on the corals. Or peppermint shrimp won't eat aiptasia for three months---and then, bang! the aiptasia start disappearing. First time one of your fishes disappears 'for no reason'---look askance at that shrimp! that's your most likely culprit.
 
Again, thank you, Sk8r. Part of my confusion as I'm getting into this is there seems to be about 18 common names per each species, and at this point I just can't keep track of what is what.

I propose we all just start speaking in latin. For the noobs like myself. ;)
 
Now you said watchmen gobies and tiger shrimp... what about other species of gobies? Do they all prefer tiger shrimp as well? Just curious, as I was looking at a red banded shrimp, Alpheus randalli, on Live Aquaria and they were saying Alpheus randalli will pair with shrimp gobies.

Looking for some more clarification since a nano means I can't get the symbiotic relationship of clown and anemone easily, so I'm interested in the shrimp/gobie duo.

FYI...I have an Alpheus randalli and it paired with a yellow watchman goby..
 
The biggest drawback I saw to the randallis is their tendency to escape into the plumbing. But they were cute little beggars, and somebody look it up---they may be smaller than the bellulus/tiger, which would be a good thing for the safety of the watchman.
 
lol, yeah seeing that my clowns hosted a candycane and my naso and springers liked to cuddle. My tank is just strange I guess.
 
I'm really confused. I did a Google image search for CBS and it shows me pictures of the shrimp that I've seen sold and PERFORMING as cleaners. I've come close to buying one several times because I love watching the symbiosis. Sk8r, can you post a pic showing the species you are referring to please.

Thanks.
 
Back
Top