Upsize to failure

D

Deatherent

New member
I recently moved from a 55 galon reef to a 75 gallon reef. Sounds simple enough doen't it.

I took everything out of the 55 including the water and reassembled it into the 75 adding 60 pounds of live rock purchased out of a tank being moved out of state so i know it was good rock.

I hand mixed the water addition and carfully checked to make sure my salenity was around 1.028.

Now the problem. My corrals don't open my new snales have not moved from where they were dropped into the tank.

It has been 2 months since the move and it is not looking good and I am not sure what I am doing wrong.

I have a 20 high that I do nothing to other than top offs and it is glorious.

HELP
 
1.028 is a little high...especially if you are getting that reading with a hydrometer or a improperly calibrated refractometer and it is actually higher than that. In times of stress it is better to be a little lower than higher.

the ocean is at .026 more or less, why would you want to be any higher than that??

I would also maybe do a test for copper on the new tank. Just to make sure that isnt an issue.

Did you move a sandbed too?? Is there a chance that you have/have had levels of ammonia nad nitrIte due to a cycle of some kind??
 
Ok agreed but everyone I talk to gives me a different level I should be keeping my salinaty at. I will lower it ASAP.

I did move my sand bed but I have checked my ammonia levels and they are at 0. I do think my Nitrites are high because I am getting a spike in hair algea and I am not sure the best way to get it down.

Tested for copper and got a negative reading and also tested my PH which is around 8.2 which I think is a little low.

Any and all help is very much appreciated
 
What about nitrate? You obviously have a cycled tank and you nitrite should be 0 by default with your ammonia, but nitrate is a little different.
 
No matter who you talk to, if they suggest anything over 1.026 stop listening immediately. The salinity range should be between 1.021 and 1.026. Usually most people strive for around .023 - .026 unless putting a fish through hyposalinity for treatment of ich.
 
If you kept thanks for 18 years at 1.028, and the 20g high is OK - this shouldn't be a cause of changes. Although I'm keeping 1.026 ;)

If the 75g tank wasn't used for medications, and the rock was cycled, with no ammonia after addition - everything should be OK, I do that all the time. Only adding Seachem Stability (bacteria), just in case, and testing every day for a several days.

In unknown cases, I would do cleaning, water change, fresh carbon, changed every 2 days for a week, grounding probe, check an oxygen or just oxygenate a little more. Maybe Kent's Toxic Metals sponge for a short time.

When you will solve this situation, and will have more time - can you post more about 20g, that needs only top-off?
I would like to go this route too.
 
How long had the 55 been up for? Your sand bed could've gone toxic. If you've kept the salinity, PH, temp, lights, etc... then your results should be similar. The only two biological changes that you've made are stirring up your sand and adding new rock. Are you running carbon right now? Get back to the basics. I would take out the new rock, do a large water change and run some carbon for two weeks and see how things look. If things don't get better I'd say it's your sand. If they do, slowly add the rock back in and watch for deterioration. Worst case you need to replace your sand. Do some searching on sand beds. I've read everything from sand beds only last a few years to never touch your sand bed.
 
I agree that the likely problem is the sandbed. When you moved it the different layers became mixed and released material that was toxic to your inhabitants.
 
But two months?? I could understand having a problem for a couple of weeks but two months is far long enough for any sandbed/cycle problem to subside.
 
If it was the sandbed, the problem would be over after two months. If it did continue for that long, it would be noticalbe in the test readings. I'll bet on something else. How was the lighting changed? Or some other factor like temp. differences between the two tanks.
We don't know many of the tank paramaters except salinity was high.
 
He said he had high nitrates as well. Phosphate was never checked to my knowledge. He could have copper stored in the silicone of his 'new' tank, but I doubt it. I wonder if there is a dead fish stuck under a rock tucked away out of sight and out of reach causing high ammonia, which is eaten...high nitrite, which is eaten...and high nitrate, which makes his corals close and snails die. Of course if the snails haven't moved in two months, they are possibly contributing greatly to the nitrate problem.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Reignfire
Stray current
2
Replies
31
Views
1K
griss
griss
wvned
Not sure what to do
Replies
8
Views
1K
OrionN
OrionN
Brian60077
Red Sea Salt
Replies
3
Views
358
Uncle99
Uncle99
B
Left Tank for a long time, now want to reboot
Replies
8
Views
383
SantaMonica
S
M
Rock hard crushed coral sand bed
Replies
8
Views
403
Jimbob
Jimbob
Back
Top