Urchin

Betaktical

New member
I guess I'll post here since they don't have an invert forum. My tuxedo urchin died yesterday (rip Austin powers) and I want to add another urchin. I have another short spine urchin that has doubled in size. I just wanna hear some stories about the urchin experiences y'all have had and which one would be best to get next.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
The other invert forum would work, http://reefcentral.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=427, but never a problem to ask questions here so others can see as well.

I added a purple pincushion urchin a few weeks ago. Mows down algae and travels all over the tank. All my corals are attached to the rock so no problems with them, it really doesn't pick stuff up anyway. Its only ever grabbed a snail, and some spaghetti worm tubes off the sand.
 
Loved the blue spot long spine that we had. Unfortunately it passed this last weekend due to an unfortunate side effect of red slime infestation, treatment, and subsequent water chemistry.

It was great, but kind of a bulldozer. Would sometimes even take over the nori clip and eat all the seeweed keeping the fish from it.

I like our tuxedo as well, but of course you know, definitely not as active.

I'll be getting another eventually.

20160313_101026_zpsd0hdbbvf.jpg
 
Loved the blue spot long spine that we had. Unfortunately it passed this last weekend due to an unfortunate side effect of red slime infestation, treatment, and subsequent water chemistry.



It was great, but kind of a bulldozer. Would sometimes even take over the nori clip and eat all the seeweed keeping the fish from it.



I like our tuxedo as well, but of course you know, definitely not as active.



I'll be getting another eventually.



20160313_101026_zpsd0hdbbvf.jpg



Nice! Is that pic what it looks like? How big does it get? I like the look of that one


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I have 4 urchins currently in mine. A black longspine, a blue tuxedo, a Halloween, and a purple pincushion. I like all of them and they've been great cleaners. Always funny to see what they'll pick up and lug around the tank with them. Black longspines can get a little bulldozer-ish when they get bigger, but they're great otherwise, IMO.
 
Nice! Is that pic what it looks like? How big does it get? I like the look of that one


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

According to LiveAquaria, can get up to 8 inches.
http://www.liveaquaria.com/product/prod_display.cfm?c=497+530+3134&pcatid=3134

I have never seen one even close to that big. The one in my picture was about 3" across not counting spine length. I imagine it would take many years to grow a significant amount.

I will definitely be getting another when I have my tank back in check.
 
Why did your urchin die in the first place? You might want to look into that, before getting a new one. :)
 
Why did your urchin die in the first place? You might want to look into that, before getting a new one. :)



They just die sometimes. That's what happened to my urchin. All my parameters were good I acclimated him properly he had more than plenty of food so idk what else I coulda done with him. Unless there is something that I was missing but I watch my tank like a hawk. Prly a total of an hour every night just looking at everything.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
According to LiveAquaria, can get up to 8 inches.

http://www.liveaquaria.com/product/prod_display.cfm?c=497+530+3134&pcatid=3134



I have never seen one even close to that big. The one in my picture was about 3" across not counting spine length. I imagine it would take many years to grow a significant amount.



I will definitely be getting another when I have my tank back in check.



Did u have another urchin in your tank? Or did anything mess with it that u had stocked? I only have 2 clowns a cardinal a wrasse 2 cleaner shrimp and a black short spine urchin and nothing picks on my current urchin


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Why did your urchin die in the first place? You might want to look into that, before getting a new one. :)

Thanks, I'm not looking to replace it immediately.

Due to my travel schedule, I've been on the road about 90% of the time for the last few months. Maintenance in my tank faltered as I was not home to take care of water changes, chemistry, etc. (the wife is too small and has RA so she can't haul water) My tank was taken over by cyano. I battled it in the day or two here and there as I could for about two months until it started to actually suffocate and kill corals.

It got to a point I could no longer battle with lights out, blowing it off of rocks/sandbed, vacuuming, lowered feedings, very frequent water changes, etc. All the things you are supposed to do to eliminate cyano, and it wasn't working. As a last resort I used a chemical treatment (Chemiclean).

It of course did exactly what it was supposed to do and eliminated all traces of cyano within 48 hours. One has to expect side effects of such a treatment (antibiotic) as it not only kills the bad cyanobacteria, but the good denitrifying bacteria as well (what makes your rock "live" rock).

During the treatment my filter socks (that I changed twice daily during the treatment) looked like a tickle me Elmo doll and smelled worse than dark skimmate.

I was expecting this and once the treatment period was over I did several water changes, monitored water chemistry, and a small cycle occurred due to the large amount of cyano being broken down. I can only change so much water every day. Never had an ammonia spike, but the massive amount of cyano being broken down created a large and fast spike in nitrate. (from 10-20 to over 100+).

Inverts and urchins are much more susceptible to rapid changes in nitrate than fish are. The casualty of this problem was my beautiful blue spot urchin. All my shrimp, snails, fish and my tuxedo urchin made it through ok.

I'm slowly bringing down the nitrate levels still with 15 gallon every other day water changes. They were down to 60 as of yesterday.

As for the other questions: Yes I have a tuxedo, nothing messes with the urchins in my tank except sometimes the Kole Tang seems to "nip" at the spines. Hes done that since I got him and it never seemed to bother either urchin. Think he likes the taste or something.
 
They just die sometimes. That's what happened to my urchin.

No. Nothing in our aquariums "just dies". It's your responsibility as a reef keeper to learn why animals perish in your tank, before you rush out and get any more. Don't you think?
Otherwise you're going to have a lot of urchins under you belt. Animals with an average lifespan of 6 years in the wild. :)
 
Back
Top