Very Confused!

fernalfer

New member
Ok i bought 100lbs of Marco Key Largo Reef saver Dry Rock. They say that the rock is pre-cured. My question is that this rock will be going into a brand new tank. Can i just put the Dry Rock in my 120 gallon tank and start my fishless cycle. Or do i have to pre cure it like some say by putting it in a Tub/Container filled with RODI salt water and a heater and a powerhead for up to a month.

Is this really necessary with the Marco Rock? Again not adding to an established tank but will be setting up new from scratch.
 
your rock may or may not leach phosphates for an extended period of time, i've read as much as 6 months. not to mention, without the rock you will not be able to properly cycle your tank.
 
Personally I would put it into the tank and start cycling.

Rock can hold phosphate but IMO it is overplayed. If it is a real concern for you put the rock in a tub. I would personally deal with any phosphate if it became a problem after the cycle. Just my 2 cents good luck.
 
I put mine in a Brute because I had the rock before the tank. I used the time to limit the die off in the tank. Had I had the tank before the rock, the rock would have gone right in and went with the cycle. In the end you most likely end up having the same amount of time into it just not as much effort due to not needing to transfer rock from bin to tank.
 
if i were me i would add a few good looking live rocks to get a proper cycle, if youre concerned about pests get some live rocks without holes, like a plate.
 
Last edited:
I don't think you need to cure it separately, I have never seen high phosphates from my Marco Rock. If you can, however, get a couple chunks of live rock from someone's system that you know to be clean, and a couple handfuls of their live sand as well. This will really help get things started on the right foot with helpful micro biodiversity.
 
It's two different processes.
Rock that has been in high phos conditions, like underground with water passing through it from the surface, or a dirty tank, will store it up. Then when it gets in a low phos condition it will release it. If that happens in your tank, and everything else algae needs (light, nitrates etc) is present, algae will grow. So people put it in a low phos enviro with something else missing, usually light, so that the phos will be released but algae won't be able to use it to grow. That's what people are doing with brutes and phos removers like gfo reactors or lanthanum chloride. Marco is claiming they took care of that part for you already.

The other process is growing the bacteria on the rock. This "cure" is just a head start on the cycle.

I like to do both right in the tank before I turn on the lights, without a sand bed. As the rock cycles and releases phos a lot of detritus is produced. It's dead bacteria and other crud that accumulates as the bac get their population balanced and pull stuff out of the rock. If you wait until that part slows down, you can easily remove that detritus from the system. If your rock turns out to be phosy, you can easily run LC to remove it. Then once the rocks are all cleaned out and the bacteria is processing ammonia, I add sand and turn on the lights for a week or so before I start stocking.

I agree with the poster who said phos leaching is a boogeyman (except for Pukani rock, that stuff is a nightmare). I think most of the time people run dirty tanks but don't realize because the rock is soaking up the phos, then it gets "full" and stops. If it's in there from the beginning, you'll know within a week because the phos-less water it's in will start to test positive. For that reason I do wait a week before I start feeding the tank to grow cycling bacteria, since the added phos from food would mess up the test. I guess if you use ammonia that's not an issue?
 
That's what I did. I bought dry rock and just let it cycle. My rock looks great now. i still don't have fish yet, but i'm ready; just a little nervous. :uhoh3:
 
Personally I would put it into the tank and start cycling.

Rock can hold phosphate but IMO it is overplayed. If it is a real concern for you put the rock in a tub. I would personally deal with any phosphate if it became a problem after the cycle. Just my 2 cents good luck.

Tony, you took the words out of my mouth! :bum:
 
Back
Top