Water Temps ? Good read

a chiller is a good thing because some people have temp swings more than 5 degrees a day

the temp isnt the problem it is how fast it gets up to that degree


The temperature in reef aquariums should be maintained between 22-27 'C (72-80 F) for the best results, and kept as stable as posible. In our experience, the center of this temperature range, 23-25 'C (74-78 F) is ideal. ... Marshall and Clode (2004) show a maximum calcification rate at 25 'C (77 F) for the corals Galaxea and Dendrophyllia ... . Other research shows the temperature of maximum calcification rate varies depending on the local normal temperature. ... In the natural setting, the most diverse coral reefs have water temperatures between 28 and 32 'C (82 and 87 F) for several months of the year. ... Our experience with aquariums has demonstrated that the temperature in a closed aquarium should not be maintained near the natural thermal tolerances of corals; on the contrary, it should be maintained significantly lower.

(Delbeek and Sprung, 2005)


Although it has been recommended in the past that aquarium temperatures should be maintained between 24-27 'C (75-80 F), the natural temperature of many Indo-Pacific reefs, especially in the shallow areas where most corals are colected, is higher than 27 'C (80 F).

It has always been assumed that temperatures at lower than normal levels prevented the unsightly algal films on the aquarium glass and lessened the proliferation of problem hair algae. Recent trends favor maintaining somewhat more natural reef temperatures of 27-29 'C (80-84 F). The reasoning behind this increase is that the entire metabolism of the tank is raised, including those of the microbial community, detritus-processing organisms, and herbivores.

...

Temperature (Min/Max./Ave.)
Average on all tested reefs ............. 21 'C (70 F) / 30 'C (86 F) / 28 'C (82 F)
Reef with lowest temperatures ........ 16 'C (61 F) / 28 'C (82 F) / 25 'C (77 F)
Reef with the highest temperatures .. 25 'C (77 F) / 34 'C (93 F) / 30 'C (86 F)

Borneman (2001)
 
Delbeek and Sprung are the ones promoting lower temps.
Not too many other people are.

I did not know Dendrophyllia were that dependant on calcium consumption.

Everything else I already knew and advise.
 
Set to 82, rarely gets over 84.
After a couple hours at 86 I would turn the lights off and make sure your fan is running and cool things down a bit.
 
I run my tank at 80Ã"šÃ‚° and I have never seen it above 84Ã"šÃ‚°. I don't have any fans running but my tank is in the basement.
 
I would say here is the answer to temp swings ! taken right from the text .

"Most natural reefs have massive temperature swings, though, on any scale you wish to measure, daily, monthly, annually, so that is not a big deal"
 
Best thing I can say is if you have the $ for a chiller go for it,but some people buy a chiller before anything else,because they think they have to keep there tank at 76 deg. which is wrong !
The $ a chiller cost could be spent in better places,like lighting,filtration,fans,etc.
Most of the time a $10-$20 fan can solve the problem anyway if you are worried about temp. swings.
I have had 10 deg. temp swings in my basement at home and all my sps are doing great ! But I would try to keep the swing as minimal as possible,but it happens in nature and we trying to duplicate that ! Just my 2 cents keep the penny !:D
 
Back
Top