What tangs go with a hippo?

[Jonviviano]

I recently purchased a small hippo tang for my tank. I know that theree is a few species of surgeons that can go with them but i want to make sure before i buy one. I Have him in a 55G...I know this is to small for tangs but when they mature i will swap them out for youngers ones, or upgrade my tank, als i have a less amount of rockwork which means more swimming space. Ive read that a Kole tang can go with him. I was wondering if a Yellow or Purple tang would fit this profile. Any help is appreciated, thanks.

 

[BTTRFLYGRL]

Sorry but I wouldn't have placed a Hippo in a 55..and I would not recommend adding another. I would return the Hippo now, give it a chance to find a home in a larger tank and then buy fish whose adult size is more appropriate for your tank. A nice Dwarf Angel would be perfect

 

[NexDog]

A small Yellow would be fine IMO.

 

[bigbenji]

The tang police will say that even a yellow tang will outgrow a 55. I've seen a hippo in a 75 with a yellow and they ignored each other.

 

[dchao]

BTTRFLYGRL:

Please read what Jonviviano's said: "I know this is to small for tangs but when they mature i will swap them out for youngers ones, or upgrade my tank"

Do you have any reason to doubt that he/she won't do it?

If the Tang is only 1"-2" now, it's perfectly OK to be kept in a 55G.

 

[racrumrine]

I recently introduced a Hippo in a 180 that already had a Yellow and Purple. The Purple harassed the Hippo for a couple of weeks. Now they all get along; however, Hippos tend to hide a lot more than the other 2.

As stated, start planning your bigger tank now.

Best of luck,

Roy

 

[BTTRFLYGRL]

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=6700397#post6700397 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by dchao
BTTRFLYGRL:

Please read what Jonviviano's said: "I know this is to small for tangs but when they mature i will swap them out for youngers ones, or upgrade my tank"

Do you have any reason to doubt that he/she won't do it?

If the Tang is only 1"-2" now, it's perfectly OK to be kept in a 55G.

Ummmm, yes I can read. I think is a bad idea to buy a fish that will outgrow your tank thinking you will upgrade or trade it. You don't know what might happen , you may not be able to upgrade. So then you'll just return it when the fish gets too large? your going to chase the fish, remove it and take it to a petstore to be placed temporarily in a tiny tank and then who knows who they'll sell it to then..and not only do we want to add one fish that will out grow this 55, we want to add 2 Notice I said above I thought he should take it back NOW and get a more appropriate sized fish. Trading in fish IMO is irresponsible and selfish and causes unnecessary stress to the fish. If you want to keep large fish, GET A LARGER TANK! Use a little common sense and self control. Leave the big fish for people who have a proper home for them

 

[Teremei]

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=6700582#post6700582 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by BTTRFLYGRL
Ummmm, yes I can read. I think is a bad idea to buy a fish that will outgrow your tank thinking you will upgrade or trade it. You don't know what might happen , you may not be able to upgrade. So then you'll just return it when the fish gets too large? your going to chase the fish, remove it and take it to a petstore to be placed temporarily in a tiny tank and then who knows who they'll sell it to then..and not only do we want to add one fish that will out grow this 55, we want to add 2 Notice I said above I thought he should take it back NOW and get a more appropriate sized fish. Trading in fish IMO is irresponsible and selfish and causes unnecessary stress to the fish. If you want to keep large fish, GET A LARGER TANK! Use a little common sense and self control. Leave the big fish for people who have a proper home for them

Yeah I have to agree. Would you adopt a child only to say, bye bye, I don't need you anymore, and bring them back to wait in the home until someone else comes to get them? I'm sorry but I don't beleive in "borrowing fish". . If you are going to buy a fish, give it a loving home for it's lifetime. So BTTRFLYGRL's response wasn't at all unfair, but critical in a good way. People should treat fish just as good as they would a Dog or Cat. Treat them as family.

This person already has a blue tang in a 55, ok fine. Hopefully he can trade it to a GOOD home (fellow reefer with a 120 or bigger) instead of back to the fish store a year from now. But now wants to add a purple tang too? (argueable one of the most aggresive of tangs). I've never considered myself a "tang police", but it's stories like this that make me understand how they feel sometimes.

 

[mcox33]

I have a 90 gallon full of rock, I bought a yellow tang used (from someone moving out of state) Then a couple of years later got a blue from someone getting out of the hobby.

they are both about 4 inches each, they have gotten along very well and seem perfectly happy in my 90 gal.

As for trading it or selling it later if something happens and she can't get a larger tank. I was perfectly happy to get my used fish.

And in my experience most others, especially those with larger tanks are happy to find a used fish that is a little larger than the lfs is selling on average. Personally I would not want to add a 2 inch fish to a 55 gallon tank.

She should keep her fish and get a yellow about the same size to go with him and then start saving money for the larger tank. The biggest she has room for. They are beautiful. But I see no reason she can't start them out in a 55 and then get a larger tank down the road.

Would you buy a 200 gallon tank for a baby oscar. I doubt it. You put him in a 20 gallon and move him up as he grows. Better for him and you. Smaller tank easier to keep an eye on him.

JMO

 

[NexDog]

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=6700634#post6700634 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Teremei
Yeah I have to agree. Would you adopt a child only to say, bye bye, I don't need you anymore, and bring them back to wait in the home until someone else comes to get them? I'm sorry but I don't beleive in "borrowing fish". . If you are going to buy a fish, give it a loving home for it's lifetime. So BTTRFLYGRL's response wasn't at all unfair, but critical in a good way. People should treat fish just as good as they would a Dog or Cat. Treat them as family.

This person already has a blue tang in a 55, ok fine. Hopefully he can trade it to a GOOD home (fellow reefer with a 120 or bigger) instead of back to the fish store a year from now. But now wants to add a purple tang too? (argueable one of the most aggresive of tangs). I've never considered myself a "tang police", but it's stories like this that make me understand how they feel sometimes.

You just joined the tang police.

I got a hippo and a yellow when I had a 50g knowing I was going to upgrade. And upgrade I did.

 

[Teremei]

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=6700718#post6700718 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by NexDog
You just joined the tang police.

I got a hippo and a yellow when I had a 50g knowing I was going to upgrade. And upgrade I did.

Say it ain't so!! :uzi: :wave: :hammer: :lolspin:

Good that you planned from the beggining. I went from wanting to get a YT for my 55 to cringing when my friend said he wants to put a blue in his 75. What happened to me? :lol:

 

[NexDog]

It's Upgrade Syndrome - on account of your 125.

Seriously, the whole tang police and "too many fish" thing gets to me. I've seen tangs in a 50g tanks that were better off than tangs in big tanks. If you look after your fish - that's the main thing. Keep them fat, disease free and away from aggression and you'll never have a problem with me. I'd much rather see 4 or 5 small tangs in a 50 than one Ich ridden or isopod attacked tang in a 500g.

 

[kjmst29]

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=6700634#post6700634 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Teremei
Yeah I have to agree. Would you adopt a child only to say, bye bye, I don't need you anymore, and bring them back to wait in the home until someone else comes to get them? I'm sorry but I don't beleive in "borrowing fish". . If you are going to buy a fish, give it a loving home for it's lifetime. So BTTRFLYGRL's response wasn't at all unfair, but critical in a good way. People should treat fish just as good as they would a Dog or Cat. Treat them as family.

This person already has a blue tang in a 55, ok fine. Hopefully he can trade it to a GOOD home (fellow reefer with a 120 or bigger) instead of back to the fish store a year from now. But now wants to add a purple tang too? (argueable one of the most aggresive of tangs). I've never considered myself a "tang police", but it's stories like this that make me understand how they feel sometimes.

Did you just compare a child to a fish???????????? :rolleye1:

 

[BTTRFLYGRL]

Unfortunately, Your fish may not be as happy as you to be in such a cramped up environment. 5 Tangs in a 50 will lead to aggression, stress and early death. I can't see putting these beautiful creatures through such stress for my benefit.

Yes, many people become addicted [like me] and upgrade..but you never know what might happen, future problems that will prevent you from doing so.

I would much rather see fish traded to other Hobbyist, ones with larger tanks and more experience..I think that is a much better idea than taking them back to the store.

Also, I would still stick to only one..As these Tangs grow, they need more space and this is going to be trouble. Why not wait till you upgrade to add that second Tang? What's the hurry? There are plenty of beautiful fish that are more suitable for a 55

 

[RichConley]

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=6700682#post6700682 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by mcox33
I have a 90 gallon full of rock, I bought a yellow tang used (from someone moving out of state) Then a couple of years later got a blue from someone getting out of the hobby.

they are both about 4 inches each, they have gotten along very well and seem perfectly happy in my 90 gal.

As for trading it or selling it later if something happens and she can't get a larger tank. I was perfectly happy to get my used fish.

And in my experience most others, especially those with larger tanks are happy to find a used fish that is a little larger than the lfs is selling on average. Personally I would not want to add a 2 inch fish to a 55 gallon tank.

She should keep her fish and get a yellow about the same size to go with him and then start saving money for the larger tank. The biggest she has room for. They are beautiful. But I see no reason she can't start them out in a 55 and then get a larger tank down the road.

Would you buy a 200 gallon tank for a baby oscar. I doubt it. You put him in a 20 gallon and move him up as he grows. Better for him and you. Smaller tank easier to keep an eye on him.

JMO

MCOX, if you've had these fish "for a couple years" and theyre only 4 inches long, their growth has been SEVERELY stunted. Tangs (especially hippos) grow extremely quickly.

 

[Teremei]

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=6701005#post6701005 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by kjmst29
Did you just compare a child to a fish???????????? :rolleye1:

Yeah, I guess I care about ALL living creatures that way. I suppose I have a big heart, sorry of that offends you.

 

[reverendmaynard]

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=6703483#post6703483 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Teremei
Yeah, I guess I care about ALL living creatures that way. I suppose I have a big heart, sorry of that offends you.

You must love it when you see people give advice like, "ditch those fish you have and get this fish." Some people seem to think nothing more of the fish than they do the LR or the sand or the skimmer. Probably less since they cost less.

BTW: The standard response to threads like this should be... "Read this thread ."

 

[BTTRFLYGRL]

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=6703740#post6703740 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by reverendmaynard
You must love it when you see people give advice like, "ditch those fish you have and get this fish." Some people seem to think nothing more of the fish than they do the LR or the sand or the skimmer. Probably less since they cost less.

BTW: The standard response to threads like this should be... "Read this thread ."

Hee hee, notice I got my 2 cents in before it was locked:lol:

I also agree, I wish people thought more of these creatures in their care

 

[kjmst29]

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=6703483#post6703483 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Teremei
Yeah, I guess I care about ALL living creatures that way. I suppose I have a big heart, sorry of that offends you.

Either that or you don't have kids. I'm betting on the latter.....

 

[Hound]

i love it when people like to have such a opinion and insist on flamming a thread when they could just ignore it.......regardless ur opinon on tangs and tank size if you dont agree you dont have to answear save your breath for a thread that is worth posting.....assuming someone one you never met wont stick to thier word on upgrading is ignorant...You have no reason to think this person is lying.....

Maybe im soft but i like to give people their word until they prove other wise....that seems like common sense then yelling at someone for asking a question....tang police=people with nothing better to do then try to stir things up for no reason