When can I safely extend time between water changes?

JodiM

New member
Right now I am testing the water every other day and doing 20% water changes every week- on Fridays to be exact.

When can I safely push it back to 2 weeks and so on?
36 gallon with live rock, cleaner shrimp, 2 snails, 1 hermit crab, 2 small clowns, 1 yellowtail damsel and a rock flower.

TIA
 
When you can maintain stable parameters and nitrate/phosphate levels don't creep up..
20% every 2 weeks is usually just fine..

as you really have no corals or anything that consumes calcium/alk,etc.. you probably don't even need to dose those either..
 
When you can maintain stable parameters and nitrate/phosphate levels don't creep up..
20% every 2 weeks is usually just fine..

as you really have no corals or anything that consumes calcium/alk,etc.. you probably don't even need to dose those either..

Ok, thank you.
I am going to continue my testing like normal for now, but I guess I will push water out to 2 weeks, unless I start seeing problems with my water parameters.
 
It's different for every tank, for several reasons. We do water changes to remove bad stuff and add good stuff. The amount of bad stuff accumulating in the water is diff for each tank, as is the amount of good stuff being consumed. Plus diff setups vary in their tolerances for how much bad is ok, and how much good is needed.

So what you do is monitor the tank. You set a goal for bad stuff like nitrates and phosphates, and see how long it takes them to creep up over where you want them by testing the water. You watch your glass to see how long it takes to build up some algae. You watch your animals to see what they look lik when they are happy, and notice if they start to look weird (like your anemone scrunching up because the water is dirty). And you set a goal for good stuff like alk, ca, mg, and see how long it takes to start dropping too low.

Then you just change the water as often as necessary to keep everything on track. I like 10% every week until the tank is really stable (6 months-1year) then every other week. But it totally depends on your tank. Besides age, theres lots of variables like what else you are doing to remove nutrients (skimming, vacuuming sand, filters) and what you are doing to add good stuff (salt quality, dosing, kalk topoff). So the balance between adding and removing is really individual and its best to start with a normal, rule of thumb schedule and go from there.
 
It's different for every tank, for several reasons. We do water changes to remove bad stuff and add good stuff. The amount of bad stuff accumulating in the water is diff for each tank, as is the amount of good stuff being consumed. Plus diff setups vary in their tolerances for how much bad is ok, and how much good is needed.

So what you do is monitor the tank. You set a goal for bad stuff like nitrates and phosphates, and see how long it takes them to creep up over where you want them by testing the water. You watch your glass to see how long it takes to build up some algae. You watch your animals to see what they look lik when they are happy, and notice if they start to look weird (like your anemone scrunching up because the water is dirty). And you set a goal for good stuff like alk, ca, mg, and see how long it takes to start dropping too low.

Then you just change the water as often as necessary to keep everything on track. I like 10% every week until the tank is really stable (6 months-1year) then every other week. But it totally depends on your tank. Besides age, theres lots of variables like what else you are doing to remove nutrients (skimming, vacuuming sand, filters) and what you are doing to add good stuff (salt quality, dosing, kalk topoff). So the balance between adding and removing is really individual and its best to start with a normal, rule of thumb schedule and go from there.

Thank you for that! Definitely gives me things to think about.
 
Keeping all parameters stable is the goal. Regular WC's at consistent intervals avoids a lot of problems and corrects errors. It also keeps CA, Mg, dKH, and trace elements in proper balance, less need for dosing. Testing helps keep you aware of your reef and involved. Waiting for nitrates and phosphates to rise is generally trying to fix a problem after the fact. Bi-weekly WC's on a consistent schedule is a great idea. If you miss one here and there after many months/years no worries.
 
With a relatively hardy reef, once a month 30% will work; but 10% a week is easier in terms of prep and work. You can usually suck that amount out of your sump or dt without even stopping the pump---(but DO stop the ATO and don't forget to turn it back on.)
 
With a relatively hardy reef, once a month 30% will work; but 10% a week is easier in terms of prep and work. You can usually suck that amount out of your sump or dt without even stopping the pump---(but DO stop the ATO and don't forget to turn it back on.)

Yeah I just leave the pump on, and use one of the hoses and pull the water from the sump and then dump new water in.

I don't have a ATO set up. So once less thing for me to worry about I suppose
 
YOu'll need an ATO first time you have to be away from your tank for a bit: and that is not the time to learn how to make an ATO work safely.
 
YOu'll need an ATO first time you have to be away from your tank for a bit: and that is not the time to learn how to make an ATO work safely.

Ok, thanks I will look into it.
We did have our first power outage last night.. Thankfully everything worked perfectly.
 
Back
Top