they do better with the larger surface area....if you have a vent in your sump area and an external pump you can vent some of the heat from it.....remember the heat exchange that is taking place and cooling your system is from the evaporation taking place .....you need this is an optimal area with the large surface area of the DT .....the sump doesn't offer much for this and its closed up so small with heat most likely from the pump it will not be as efficient as on the DT and most of the time its a waste in the sump area