A more likely scenario is rather than extending for MORE light, they are extending because they are in competition FOR light.
Think of a rock concert. The first row stands up, then the second row (because by standing the first row is blocking them), then the third. Pretty soon the whole theatre is standing. Then the second row, to see even better, stands on their seats. Then the third follows suit, etc. etc.
I would not assume you need more light if they have done fine for months. Chances are they have spread out more, and have to reach around each other. I have two 250w MH lights on my tank, and some DIRECTLY under that light extend quite a ways. It's to be expected on healthy polyps. Why do you think they even developed the ability to extend their 'stalks'?
Think about what healthy polyps do. They open like a flower, extend, get large, reach out. Unhealthy polyps retract, close up, get flat.
I consider it a sign of health, and have polyps extending about two inches (sometimes quite a bit more) right now in my tank. Not every type has the ability, but those that do, reach out.
nalbar