220 Inwall - Plan

Status
Not open for further replies.
Wow, get stuck in meetings all day and come back to some good dialog....

Marc -
I'm not a fan of baserock. I know it saves a bunch of money, but it won't really start acting as natural filtration until it is well established. That can take up to 6 months. My tank doesn't have any baserock at all. I used what I had, and acquired more LR from club members in the area. LR is up for sale all the time, and buying it from others runs $2 to $4 per pound.

- I hear you, and alot of other people. See more on this below.

I don't think you need the shrimp.....Due to the volume of water in your system, I'm thinking you can add your fish and they will do the same job as the shrimp would have. Just don't add anything else for about a month.

- Cool. I like this plan!

Your holding system isn't really ideal, now that I'm thinking about it.

- Well, I'm not going to use it for QT. All new fish will sit in a 6 week QT beforehand.


Conda -
I agree with Marc on the base rock and I think that was one of my problems. I used half LR and half BR and it took the base over 6 months to start turning live. A year later, only one side of it looks like LR, the other side still looks like base.

- Wow! I didnt realize it would take this long.

If you look in the PARC forum, someone in West Chester is selling 70lbs of it cheap right now.

- Well....:eek: guess what!?!?! I checked out a link to a local forum from Conda and am buying 55lbs of live rock for about $2 a lb from a guy. And...strangest thing....he works in my company! One floor above me!


rdmpe -
No problem. Share alike in this thread!!

Marc -
Buying it from a local or from a LFS is no different. What causes it to cycle is being exposed to air, especially if there are sponges dying off due to air-exposure. Wherever you buy it, bring a bucket or two, and keep it submerged in saltwater. You can even bring the bucket with 2.5g of saltwater in it, so they just pull the rock and put it right back into the water, incase they don't have enough to give you.

Buying LR from individuals does have its drawbacks, so keep in mind that you want to look for: flatworms, hitchhikers, nuisance algae, etc. The stuff at the LFS may have hitchhikers or flatworms too, but usually their stuff looks a little more barren. I try to buy it covered with coralline if at all possible.

I saw the advice another guy gave you about using only 25% LR and 75% baserock, and I'll just say I disagree. Of course, if you'll re-read his thread, you can figure out when he set up the tank, and you'll notice he has a very small bioload (just look at the pictures). He's waiting for it to get well established.

- Now that I'm buying it from a local person, whats the best way to examine it? ALso, he's gonna bring it into the office, about 20 mins away, in a cooler with the pieces wrapped in wet paper towel. I'll then rush it home. Should be no prob.
 
bheron said:
- Well....:eek: guess what!?!?! I checked out a link to a local forum from Conda and am buying 55lbs of live rock for about $2 a lb from a guy. And...strangest thing....he works in my company! One floor above me!
That's funny. What company do you two work for?
 
If you want to really examine it, put it in a separate tank and put each rock on a pedestal of eggcrate. Then you can look at it over time, and see what crawls out of it. Put some shrimp in the corner (a few chunks) and see if anything curious crawls out to get the food. If it is a good guy, keep it. If it is a bad one, like a gorilla crab, you can safely remove the rock and not introduce the bad crab into your tank.

Typically the seller should give you a heads up about what may lurk in the rockwork.

If you want to 'cook' the rock a little before introducing it into your tank, that is an entirely different topic.
 
Interesting. Thats a good idea. Yea, I beleive the guy will give me a good heads up, but you can never be sure whats in your own rock. I was figuring on cooking it anyway, just to clean it out a bit. BUt, observing it in my "observation tank" might be a good way to check it after its clean? hmmm?
 
Right now I still have this massive sand storm in the tank. Real bummer, but thats what comes with southdown. I'm hoping that when I put some of this LR in the tank the bacteria will settle things down a bit. Very frustrating.

Ok, two more items up next I wanted to run by everyone:

1) The overflow drains. The pic in the previous page shows the drains just emptying straight into the sump. Well, a heck of alot of noise is created by this. I'm eventually going to install a bubble trap like the one marc invented, but i still have to silence the noise. So, instead of having them go straigt down at a 0 degree angle, I put 90 degree bends on them and have them enter the water like this:

tank1107050004.jpg


It definitely makes a big difference. Any other ideas on how to silence the huge gush of water?

2) Also, I'm thinking about ideas for my background. I know alot of people either a) paint their tank backs or b) paint acrylic and use that. I dont want to do either. I saw some really cheap ($2.25) pieces of 1/8" thick hardboard at HD the other day. You know, that brown stuff they use and put holes in for pegboard to hang your tools? Well, the stuff is really lightweight. I was hoping I could paint these blue and use them for my background. I want something inexpensive, lightweight, removable, and blue! I think this idea will work. Thoughts?
 
bheron said:
Right now I still have this massive sand storm in the tank. Real bummer, but thats what comes with southdown...
I'm going to be doing the same thing in the next few weeks, putting southdown in the tank for the first time. So a couple of questions...
- Do you wash any of the fines out first? I was not planning to do this as I thought that was part of the benefit of southdown...
- Do you run all of your circulation pumps as you normally would? I thought I should just run the pumps. If I don't, I'll get things settled down then turn the pump on and find the sand gets blown around in certain areas and I'll have milk again...

...The pic in the previous page shows the drains just emptying straight into the sump. Well, a heck of alot of noise is created by this....
If you have two drains available you might want to try this
http://www.reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=344892
I set it up and it works perfectly. It is silent. And it does not bring any bubbles into the sump.

For backgrounds, I prefer to roll some latex paint onto the exterior of the glass.
 
I got a minimal sandstorm when I started up my pumps. Best to start them up now and see if any flow patterns you have are going to be moving things around; I had to adjust a few nozzles in my setup once I turned on the closed loop and realized it was going to blast the sand off front half of the tank.

Marc's suggestion to get the plastic cardboard is a great one. I was trying to remember what it was called but couldn't. I used that stuff for a number of projects in my tank; shrouds for my canopy fans, a cover for the "splashy end" of the sump, and a cover for my overflow. It's dirt cheap and easy to work with...

One thing to mention about mounting a piece of something outside the tank rather than painting... I noticed with my setup that the color of my acylic backing doesn't show through as well as I thought. I have the same color blue acrylic that's covering my overflow on the outside back of the tank:
DSCN4030.sized.jpg


Could just be how I positioned my lights but I had wanted the background to be all one color, but it doesn't look that way in my setup..

IF you're going black you'll be fine though.

Tyler
 
Marc -
You just need a sheet of cloroplast. You can see a tiny image of some here:

- WOW! This is cool b/c I have a good friend in the sign business. I never heard of this stuff, but I have a feeling its the same stuff he uses allthe time. I'm gonna research this as soon as I'm done this post.

See! RC is the best!

Marc -
To solve the noise in the sump since you haven't made a bubble tower yet:

- So you think this might be better than the bubble tower? And, come to think of it, I dont think bubbles will be a problem in my large sump. Should I implement this idea first? Seems pretty easy.

rdmpe -
- Do you wash any of the fines out first? I was not planning to do this as I thought that was part of the benefit of southdown...

- I've used southdown before and have been through this. Def dont wash it first. the fine granules are one of the benefits of using southdown. What I did, and it worked well this time around, is put the sand in the tank first -- dry. then i filled the tank slowly. for me, I used my RODI directly so it filled so slowly i had literally no storm! Once the pumps start up, however, it will be inevitable. So I dont see any way out of it - you can just minimize it hopefully. Once the bacteria cycle starts, the sand will become coated and will weight down more. My question posted was about using skimmer to help. I've seen people do this but not sure if it really helps?

- Also, I'll have to check out that thread on silencing the noise in the sump! Thanks! I'll let you know what I find.

Tyler -
One thing to mention about mounting a piece of something outside the tank rather than painting... I noticed with my setup that the color of my acylic backing doesn't show through as well as I thought. I have the same color blue acrylic that's covering my overflow on the outside back of the tank:

- Thats a really good point. It will look very different.

Which brings me to another ques: what kind of paint do I use? I assumed spray paint but dont know where to get it? I checked out paint at HD already and found a nice color of latex. Also, I'm expecting to get water on the background occasionally.


Ok, off to check out a couple of things you guys posted here. Thanks!
 
bheron said:
Tyler -

- Thats a really good point. It will look very different.

Which brings me to another ques: what kind of paint do I use? I assumed spray paint but dont know where to get it? I checked out paint at HD already and found a nice color of latex. Also, I'm expecting to get water on the background occasionally.


I imagine latex would work fine. Spray paint should be available at Home Depot, any of the standard rustoleum paints would be fine. Personally I'd use regular latex and roll is on; I'm HORRIBLE with spray paint and the background wouldn't look too hot if I did it that way. :lol:

You may want to look into the "plastic cardboard" more with your friend in the sign business. I bought mine in white a the local hardware store. It was also available in red and yellow. Your friend in the sign business may be able to get it in a color you like and then there'd be no worries about paint.

Tyler
 
Ok, just got off the horn. The wheels are in motion. At tailgate at next week's Monday night football game between the Eagles and the Cowboys, I'll get to pick out my choice of absolutely any color in the rainbow and my buddy will get me the cloroplast custom made. He say's the stuff is impervious to any weather so I wont have to worry about that. And its cheap! Cool!

Thanks so much!
 
If you decide on painting the back of the glass, I personally have tried spray paint and the roll on latex. Roll on latex is the way to go. Spray paint is 10X more difficult and time consuming.

Did I mention that plumbing method is silent? :) I love it. My tank is right behind my couch in the room with the TV, so it has to be very quiet...
 
Def not painting the back of the tank. Thanks.

But I stil have to check out that link to the silent design!
 
rdmpe - I checked out that link, the design by "herbie". It looks like this is a design for the overflow boxes? If so, I'm looking for something to silence the water splashing into the sump. My overflow boxes both have durso standpipes in them and I have no noise whatsoever. Did I misread? Or not read far enough?
 
Bryan,
You got it right; the overflow solution in that thread is to silent the overflow boxes..

In my case it did help with noise in the sump because I was no longer pushing a mixture of air and water into the sump. With just straight water going into the sump with no air mixed in the sump is very quiet too.

Tyler
 
bheron said:
WOW! This is cool b/c I have a good friend in the sign business. I never heard of this stuff, but I have a feeling its the same stuff he uses allthe time. I'm gonna research this as soon as I'm done this post.

See! RC is the best!
Me too!! I'm glad Marc brought this up.. I never thought about it. I don't want to paint it because I want to be able to see in the tank from the back. Great Idea!!
 
To silent my sump I have my over flow pipe flowing into a used Salt bucket with holes drilled through out the bottom of the bucket and a hole in the lid to allow the pipe to enter. Also works as a bubble trap.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top