A simple solution for sps keeping idea.

Picoreefer,

I think you get the idea of what most of us are doing and what one of us apparently isn't.

The more advanced and honed your skills are, the more you can get away with. A well trained eye and understanding of the basics will allow you to pick up on many problems before they happen. The technology and gadgets that many of us use to grow and color our SPS will do no good in the wrong hands without a well armed understanding of what makes SPS thrive.

Saying that anyone can run an SPS tank like most run a fish tank is a fallacy. Nobody makes the transition with much success by accident. A full blown SPS tank with corals popping out of the water gets harder and harder to maintain as the corals grow. Water volume will be displaced by the corals, and proper flow patterns will need to be increased to account for more filled in space. When this starts to happen, you will need additional supplementing and maintenance to get the same results. You may even need to perform larger water changes to keep nuisance algae and nutrient build up in check. The sand bed you could once vacuum is no longer accessible and the beautiful aquascape you filled in with corals will need to be maintained/trimmed to keep SPS colonies from overtaking each other. You'll have many people tell you that anything's possible, but you need to look at what the majority of SPS keepers are doing to get a true feel for what can be expected.

The hobby has come a long way in the last 10 years, and the chances of keeping a successful SPS aquarium is much more possible because of the tools we have available...not in spite of them.
 
Picoreefer,

...you need to look at what the majority of SPS keepers are doing to get a true feel for what can be expected.

The hobby has come a long way in the last 10 years, and the chances of keeping a successful SPS aquarium is much more possible because of the tools we have available...not in spite of them.

+1, Well said Alex.
 
No I'm implying that you come off rather abrasive and over opinionated. We've been down this road before You also make a lot assumptions about how people do things and tend to talk down to people. Those who live in glasses houses shouldn't throw stones.

Is my tank over complicated? Does the addition of filter socks being the only major difference in our systems a cause to label my tank "over complicated", or maybe that I need to re-dial in my alk to match a recent growth spurt in my tank a cause for to be labeled "over complicated" .

No I have never claimed not to have things die on me. I openly speak of tanks crashing and troubles I've had over the years I don't hide it like some people. See any of my build threads on this user name or my prior.

Do the things you have to do "regardless" not count as maintenance, and husbandry? Because I'm pretty sure when I tore down my tanks and took a break I didn't have to do or worry about anything reef related. All those things are apart of tank maintenance and husbandry. To assume all the little things are a part of maintenance is just silly. Do I top off manually, do I have an ATO? How big is the ATO Jug? What Type of ATO system do I have, how do I have it plumbed in? Do I have my RO/DI fill my ATO bucket w/a float valve or fill it up manually when needed. Is my float valve working, does it need to be cleaned, is my bucket dirty, are my hoses slimy, do they need to be replaced.. it goes on and on. All these choices/decisions create different levels of maintenance/attention required for our tanks, and that's just in regards to ATO. Pretending you like don't do anything but casually toss some food in as you walk by your tank every other day is really misleading to a lot of people as some people have this weird obsession with making it seem like everything is "no big deal" and requires no effort at all. The purpose these forums is for people to congregate and discuss how we keep our tanks, exchange thoughts and ideas around a central community of like minded people not to blow people off with this elitist "pssh I can do it without even looking at my tank so the rest of you smut be idiots attitude", It's not helpful.

On a side note you say these things happen regardless of the tank you run. I disagree you can get away with a lot if you run a softie or fowlr tank you'd be surprised. Top off one a week, tap water, no dosing or carbon reactor. Water changes bah what's that.. maybe once every 6 month, carbon I guess the tank is looking a little yellow... :ape:

+1 Well said.
I just wish this site was more friendly and less abrasive!
 
So the conclusion of this thread is SPS tanks are beautiful but not easy/simple to maintain:

1. Heaps of equipment and cables
2. Need to dose multiple additives/frequent water changes
3. Need to test and monitor frequently
4. Cannot go on long vacations and just let the friend come over to feed fish
5. A lot more expensive than fowlr
6. Some things can be automated but the need for a computerised controller tells you something..

I suppose by doing a full SPS tank, you just have to admit that it will be a lot of work and commitment.
 
Last edited:
150g sps dominant tank, 2 skimmers that are undersized by drains in each side of sump, lights on timers, ATO (float, relay, aqualifter) with Kalkwasser. powerheads, chiller, fans in canopy, manually dose magnesium and two part as needed along with other supplements

Basic equipment here. Everyone and every tank is different, what works for me may not work for you.
 
Back
Top