Aggressive.

Sk8r

Staff member
RC Mod
In general, aggression is a function of tank size. Put a fish in too small a tank and bad attitude happens. Damsels have a horrid reputation, but are perfectly manageable in 100 gallons. Foxfaces have a panic reflex if confined that (considering their poison spine) can prove lethal to tankmates: they grow up and one day no different than any other day, they do a freakout. Same with tangs: can be fairly mild until their size and the tank size produce stress: then you have war.

There are, however, predators---carnivores that will, yes, prey on other species. Obviously tank size is not going to prevent this: you just have to know [read! ask!!!] not to house certain species together, or you will be providing a very expensive diet for one fish.

In short, when you set up your tank, plan on SOMEBODY (usually only one fish) reaching max size in about a year. And if you haven't looked it up (or asked) to find out what that is, you may find yourself owning a fish no store wants and a tank much too small for those behaviors.

As a rule, too, plan to add your more 'pushy' fish last. It's a skillset, to be able to introduce smaller fish into a tank with a dominant pushy fish: can be done, but depends on species and, again, tank size, available cover, and the built-in instincts of the fish being added. If you can get them through a week with everybody still alive, the big guy may forget they're newcomers.

Avoid mated pairs of anything, even clowns, unless you have room for the behavior change: a breeding pair of damsels (yes, clowns) takes, yes, twice the territory of a singleton, and will enforce that.

Pay close attention, always, to the alkalinity of your tank: this is the buffer level, what keeps the water 'nice' and non-irritating and keeps your fishes' protective slime coat in good shape, a protection against wounds, parasites, and infections. I like to keep mine at about 8.3. If you can't make it stay put, you're low in magnesium: keep that about 1350.

In general, a tank with multiple fish can have action and movement without nipped fins or the risk of them. Remember there's no fish your LFS can offer that won't likely be available for you to order, so don't worry about 'missing' your chance at a specific fish. When you're ready for it, when you know enough about the species to know you can house it properly with room to grow, then's the go-ahead. Random fish shopping and whim of the week is not the way to success. Planning and making intelligent choices will give you a really great tank, of whatever size.
 
Very helpful and good to know. I have a 125 with 6 fish and maximum size on them is less than 4 inches. All reef safe. One fish is getting pick on. Happens in all tanks I'm sure.
 
Most often when one fish is catching flak, it's a competitor of the same species, a potential mate, a potential rival. Also, the stronger fish will claim the best sleeping holes, and that can cause a rivalry. SO can territory. You might try moving one rock and seeing if that scrambles the landmarks enough to calm them down. In my 105 gallon, damsels constantly push and bluff, but this is just what they do, and nobody ever gets bitten: everybody knows their 'place' and when they stray into somebody else's the owner of that space flares up and chases, but stops when the offender is back in his territory. Feeding time scrambles everybody---and there's no lines; but as soon as the food is gone, there's bluff and chase until everybody is back in his own 'spot.' This is why putting multiple damsels in anything under a hundred gallons is a problem.

In my own 105, for instance, I have one-of-a-kind on the big dominant fish, which is the way she likes it. I CAN have multiples on the smaller fish she rules: they don't prolong demonstrations among themselves where She-who-must-be-obeyed can see, because she will move over there and they will all run for cover. And nobody ever gets bitten or damaged. But because they are highly territorial and under the governance of the big gal, it's not a good idea to add any fish of a different kind. Damsel tanks are tricksy and not what I'd advise for beginning reefers, precisely because if you ever have to add a fish to the company once they sort out into ruler and ruled, it's difficult to get a new fish of any species in safely. Can be done, but not easily. Fishy politics is one of those things you learn over time. ;)
 
Last edited:
I have a 150 gallon 60X24X24. I have two yellow tail damsels that get along great and show no aggression to any other fish. Was thinking about adding a third since I've been told they prefer odd numbers. Is that too many yellow tails for my tank?
 
Put the new guy in a net for entry. Carry the net to the bottom of the tank and release the new guy into the rockwork at the opposite end of the tank from where the other guys hang out. If a fight results anyway, turn out the lights. If it won't quit, move a rock. In general the presence of a larger fish they're all respectful of will prevent a fight breaking out in the first place, but if it happens, you can try all the above and hope the new guy has the common sense to get deep into the rockwork somewhere and stay there. The yellowtails are pretty peaceful souls as is, but a 150 should give them additional room to sort it all out. If you're going to try multiples, the most reasonable of the damsels to try it with are the yellowtails and the Fiji blues.
 
Awesome, thanks! I wanted to do a trio of the yellowtails, a trio of royal grammas, and a trio of blue green chromis.
 
I've read clowns should really only be kept it pairs.

I am planning on putting a pair of Onyx clowns in a 75 with 6-7 or so other small semi aggressive fish. Is this unwise??
 
Clowns can generally hold their own.

Re the chromis with damsels---just don't put them in with dascyllus damsels or red clowns. I found this out the hard way...dascyllus types (and that includes the red clowns if other behavioral similarities extend that far) absolutely hate them.
 
Back
Top