Algae Scrubber help please

I am installing an external algae scrubber in my system. I am going to buy two of the exact same pumps(putting one in my sump) and one in a 20 gallon tub. Water will be pumped from the sump(first compartment) into the scrubber(hanging over the tub) then the pump(in the tub) would return the water back in to the sump(in the last compartment of the sump). Any thing wrong with this???
 
I suggest using only one pump. Get a small tank and drill an overflow for it that will gravity feed back to your main sump. Or build your own acrylic box to do the same thing. Feed the pump directly to your scrubber and let that water fill up your small tank and gravity feed back to the sump.

You need at least 35 GPH per inch of screen length assuming waterfal style scrubber and remember you'll have considerable flow rate loss due to head pressure.

There are alternative scrubber methods you could try as well. Submerged, Upflow algae scrubber, or floating scrubber: if there is simply not enough room for the waterfall scrubber.
 
Ok so what about this? Think about a wet dry and then could I just put a pump in the second section(after bio balls) and have it feed the algae scrubber? Or would it not be cleaning only dirty water so it would be ineffective? I could have the pump installed under the bio balls and feed the scrubber in the second compartment. Would that be better?
 
Having tried a waterfall scrubber above the sump and an up-flow scrubber in the sump, I would recommend you consider an up-flow. The plumbing and properly sized screen feed made this a nightmare in an already tight cabinet. Worked but cumbersome maintenance. My up-flow unit sits inside the skimmer chamber of the sump and is lit by LEDs through the sump side glass. The only connection is a 1/4" airline fed by a small air pump. Dirt simple, quiet and very space conscious.
 
Ok so what about this? Think about a wet dry and then could I just put a pump in the second section(after bio balls) and have it feed the algae scrubber? Or would it not be cleaning only dirty water so it would be ineffective? I could have the pump installed under the bio balls and feed the scrubber in the second compartment. Would that be better?

I wouldn't be concerned with 'clean' vs 'dirty' water in your system at any given point. To my understanding, the wet-dry should help with NH3/4 converting bacteria, but will leave plenty of NO3 in the water for algae to grow on your scrubber. Your algae grows via photosynthesis, which requires nitrogen (usually in form of NH3 or NO3), phosphorus (usually in form of PO4), light, and a few other elements, such as iron, potassium, and some other smaller trace elements that are not as likely to be limiting factors.

Point being - your system will most likely have plenty of nutrients for your scrubber to consume.

Ultimately - as far as design goes, get on the ATS basic thread and figure out flow rate, size, lighting requirements, etc, and then figure out where that will fit into your sump. They are typically easy to DIY, but sometimes challenging to fit into existing systems. Many times the most challenging part is to fit lighting in, so knowing the type and size of your lighting is important in this process. Also mentioned is the upflow scrubber which is a good idea for those who cannot fit the waterfall scrubber in place.

If there is no room in the sump, and you definitely want to do the waterfall style scrubber, your previous mentioned idea of pumping water up into a separate container will work, you will just want to gravity feed from the above tank back into your sump vs trying to use two pumps. You asked for a diagram in your PM. I was trying to explain something like this:

temp.jpg
 
Back
Top