My mini-review:
Your Reef: Great SPS frags, good fish and food selection too. I've been there one too many times and always want to go back

My current favorite.
O Street: They have some great LPS pieces at times. If any SPS, its usually rather overpriced for what it is. No listed prices on corals. I've never lost a fish purchased from them. Decent dry goods selection, sometimes have prices a dollar over Dr. Foster&Smith for IO and ReefCrystals, so great location for salt.
Capital: Some good LPS, usually brown SPS. Mixed on the fish quality - but they have been putting dates on when they received the livestock on the tanks which is a nice idea. Dry Goods are double-plus-expensive (compared to online).
AquaLife: Just checked them out today, very nice store, but very far for me. Did get a really nice Derasa clam though. Limited dry goods selection from first impression.
Exotic: Recently moved and their coral tanks are currently a diatom mess

Huge new location though, will probably improve as they bring more corals in. Their SPS selection before the move was mixed though - stuff at Your Reef is much nicer for the price (and overall). Store has a lot of potential though, I'll give it time. Good fish selection.