Bumble bee snails - good or bad

MDP

New member
The title has it.

Any opinions on these chaps? A friend heard that they were predatory, I have read they are pretty ineffective scavengers. Anyone got any experiences (good or bad).

They certainly made light work of a clam that died recently in my tank, but would they have killed it?

Matt
 
I don't think that they would have killed the clam.from what I know they are scavengers.
can you post some pics of you and your friends tanks? from what I hear you guy's in Japan have some awesome tanks!
 
I agree with mbbuna, they are fairly good algae eaters as well, but I do believe they are actually predatory.
 
I've heard this before but have a bunch in with Croceas and a Maxima for years, no problems. They are great when something dies, you'll see a pile on and instant clean up of carcass.
 
Dr Ron has been answering questions on bumblebees for several years now:

Engina species = Bumble bee snails

Bumble bee snails, sometimes erroneously referred to as bumble bee Nassarius, are small whelks in the family Buccinidae. These snails are from one to two centimeters long. The shell is black or dark brown and has a yellow or white stripe spiraling around the shell. This gives an appearance that is not unlike the yellow and black banding pattern of some wasps or bees, hence the common name. These animals are characterized by a more-or-less rectangular aperture, with a thickened outer edge. This outer edge typically has several bumps or swellings on its inner or apertural side. In fully adult animals, the aperture may be quite narrow. There is a short, narrow "spout" or siphonal canal. These animals lack the groove behind the siphonal canal, further indicating that they are not Nassarius.

Buccinids are typically predatory, and Engina species are no exception. Some Engina species are known to prey on polychaetes, however the species found in aquaria, probably closely related to Engina mendicaria, are poorly known. Being buccinids, all Engina will be primarily predatory, but probably they will also be able to act as scavengers eating uneaten food or carrion. Bumble bee snails have occasionally been seen to eat other snails, although this is probably not their major food source in aquaria. They have been reported as not apparently causing any apparent problems, although these observations are generally from aquaria that have sand beds. In these aquaria, the snails are likely eating sand-dwelling polychaete worms.

Bumble bee snails are found in shallow water throughout the Indo-Pacific and are fairly hardy. They will do well at standard reef temperatures and salinities.

I do not consider these animals reef safe in the broadest sense, but they are small and if only a few are in a tank they are likely not to cause apparent problems.


Note - this was a response back in 2004. He had a similar response in 2002. I don't know if his position has changed since then (doubt it).

Good luck!
 
Back
Top