Clam half gone

ArchiReef

New member
I came home from work today and my new beautiful clam was half gone. It appears to have been eaten. It would have been a lot of meat too. What could have done this? I have a pair of clowns and flameback and a 6 line wrasse. I also have some hermits and an emerald crab. Can the clam grow back or is he done for?
 
Sorry to hear about your clamy. I just got myself a crocea a week ago and I can imagine how much that must suck.

you should probably look a little more deeply into what the cause of it was. There are so many things that could contribute to it dying.

Overall water quality
feeding
original health of the clam before purchased (biggest thing imo)
livestock
parasites
lighting
etc

etc...

What was up with the clam the day before? Was it gaping? closed?
 
Clam looked fine the day before when the lights were on. Open showing off its colors.This thing looks like it was attacked. Flesh is all torn up and half of it is just gone. Litterally half of it is gone other half still there.
 
Water parameters, placement, lighting change, flow change, possibly a predator. Clams die like that. There typically isn't a lot of warning when it comes to clams. One day they look great one day they are clean up crew fodder. I had a clam for 6 months that did the same exact thing.
 
sorry to hear about your clam :sad1: i will follow this thread because i am thinking of getting one soon.
 
My vote goes to the Flameback....most are regarded as clam nippers and once they get a taste for it, no clam would be safe in the tank again.
 
Any chance you have a wrasse in the tank? I have lost many clams to the "half eaten" problem. I think it is my Lime wrasse, but I could be drastically wrong. This fish just seems to have the biggest belly and biggest smile everytime it happens.

-=E=-
 
Thanks for the insight. I kept a close eye on the clam since I knew the flameback is known for nipping but he came from a tank that had 3 clams in it. I never saw him so much as nip at the clam the 3 days the clam was in the tank alive
 
wait hold on, SO the clam was in the tank for only 3 days?

Thats probably the cause. How long did the LFS have the clam before you bought it? I waited for beyond the reef to have it for more than 3 weeks before I bought mine. That is the hardest part to getting a clam, getting one thats healthy to start with.
 
I agree with Khan. Sometimes you don't even have to have a predator in your tank to lose a clam. I'm no expert on clams, but IMOE, they look like they've been eaten up when they die. That happened to 2 of my clams that was only in my tank for about a week. But I have clams of the same kind that has been in the same tank for years and still alive.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=13103602#post13103602 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Ladipyg
My vote goes to the Flameback....most are regarded as clam nippers and once they get a taste for it, no clam would be safe in the tank again.

i agree
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=13103820#post13103820 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by ArchiReef
Thanks for the insight. I kept a close eye on the clam since I knew the flameback is known for nipping but he came from a tank that had 3 clams in it. I never saw him so much as nip at the clam the 3 days the clam was in the tank alive

I have seen angels act as model citizens for years, and then all of a sudden turn like a jeckel and hyde without notice until its too late
 
^No they can be exposed just don't let them dry out (think about low tide in the ocean) also plus 4 on the flameback
 
Is the clam still alive? Does it open and close with only half of it gone?

Clams are really sensitive and may die unexpectedly. Unless we have proof, it is tough to point the finger at the flameback. It sounds like an acclimation issue. I am no expert though, and that is just my opinion.
 
Clam is dead/gone as of this morning. I knew I wanted a clam so when I got the flameback I was hesitant but when I saw the guy's tank with clams in it I thought he was a safe bet. I got the flameback from puspana here on RC.
 
Are you running a phosban reactor to deal with phosphate, etc. in the water? Many clams did not do well with them....since then I have my phosphate reactor in line with a reactor filled with carbon. Since I use Power UltraPhos by Fauna Marin it doesn't need to be changed as often as carbon, so I change the carbon twice to once of the Ultra Phos. My 2 clams are fine, one large and one small and I've had them for over a year.
Do a search on the Clam, Mollusk forum and you'll see a number of threads on it. Try "clams and GFO" or "clams and phosphate remover".
A clam dying that fast after acquiring it could have had problems to start with. But I have no doubt that the Flameback had a taste after it was dead and you will not be able to trust it again with a clam in the tank.
A slow acclimation and a good scrubbing of the outer shell are in order.
Also if you have Narrasius snails and did not put your clam onto a piece of rock for it to attach its "foot" to and it began to burrow down in the sand to find something solid, the snail may have eaten it's foot off. I have never had a problem with that since I place all my clams onto hollowed out pieces of rock so their foot is protected at all time, but I do know people who have placed clams on the sand only to find the snails having a feast. Also makes it easier to move them when I want and I don't damage them at all. Narrasius snails are a great clean up crew, but always hungry and a clam foot is just too good for them to pass up.
 
Back
Top