When pH probes begin to fail they respond to changes in pH slower, they do not read incorrectly - until they are well along in their death spiral. The proper way to check a probe is during during routine cleaning and calibration. Go through the calibration process in the normal way, but pay attention to the time it takes for the probe reading to stabilize after moving from the low pH calibration solution to the high pH solution. If it takes longer than ~30 seconds, the probe is either dirty or beginning to fail. All pH probes wear out and fail in this manner. "Lab" grade probes "usually" last longer then "standard" probes. Many people use probes well beyond their actual useful life because they seem to be giving them the reading they expect. This is OK as long as you don't use the pH reading to control anything critical, such as a Ca reactor.
Also, a great cleaning solution for the pH probe is the 4.0 calibration solution. Dip it and scrub the probe tip gently with a soft bristle toothbrush.