No, the upwelling is pretty rich here, the kelps grow at amazing rates, 300ft per year.
I'd say current and reef crest type flows are best(at least 2x a day), along with a good Chiller and bright daylight lighting.
I've been up and down this coast at all times of the year, same for the Florida Key's. Some species appear seasonally, Ulva was plaguing things here a few months back, but now is mostly gone.
Mermaid's wine glass seems to be rare in the winter in Florida, but is all over in the summer/spring. Reds seem to like winter in general.
I plan on using a 3000gph powerhead in a 65cm cube + 150 HQI light that moves with the same roation as the sun(I use a telescope worm drive+ a rail to move the unit)
High current knocks the micro pest algae off it seems to me.
There's just too much strong energy too often to maintain a noxious amount. Also, the growth rates outpace many smaller noxious algae as well as being high and dry a few hours 2x a day tidally.
I really do not want a high and dry tank for 2x each day and want a 60 gallon sump either.
But it could be engineered........
I can recreate the energy pretty well with the powerhead(It's a nice one).
Light, will be pretty good, about 500-600 micro moles over most of the area.
Water nutrients will be pretty close to that of the natural system, perhaps a tad richer except for PO4.
Regards,
Tom Barr