RichConley
New member
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=10644803#post10644803 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by MiddletonMark
Well, many of my corals come from Fiji, as is common throughout the hobby in the U.S.
At least according to Walt Smith in Fiji, the reefs there average more in the mid 70's for most of the year.
http://reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&postid=5089918#post5089918
[and, he notes numerous issues with higher temps causing bleaching/death].
Personally, given his history, I discount many things said by Shimek .... esp when someone involved in the coral collection disagrees. If I'm betting with someone on this, I'd go with the guy in Fiji vs. the guy in Montana.
First, I'd trust the university of the south pacific more than i'd trust walt smith's thermometer.
IIRC, when he spoke at Imac last year, he talked about having different areas, some in the 70s, some in the 80s, and not really losing corals till they hit the 90s. (and no one is saying 90s are good)
I dont get what people's issue with Shimek is. He got in a fight with Bomber ( and didnt everyone?), and that was pretty much it, other than being kind of curmudgeony. I've never seen any problems with the integrity of his work.
If you have a problem with his numbers, post other information, dont take jabs at him