Dead fish already from Beverlys

Lacy

Ex FMAS bod member
Premium Member
I got a Banggai Cardinal fish on Friday at the sale. He died last night :( He seemed to be doing fine. We checked the parameters before we put him in there and after he died. They were fine. Never had a fish die on me so fast before.
Anyone have this problem before from there? I dont think that I will be getting fish there anymore.
 
Beverlys doesn't carry the healthiest fish and is common practice to say "you get what you pay for." I would never buy fish from them or similar stores with the same practices.

How did you aclimate the fish?


-Matthew
 
ya happened to me as well. i picked up a affrican leapord wrasse on tuesday. he dies the next day. i wanted the one of the ones in their frag tank but the manager said no becuase they were "good algea eaters".. in other words the colors were awsome and they survived the acclimation and have been there for about a month... i hate it when stores do that, they keep the best of the shipments for there "display" tanks. i have never bought a fish before that came straight outta the bag, and thats the last time i do.. i think thats the last time i get fish from there as well..
 
Im not giving Beverlys a plug or anything, but Ive bought fish from them in the past and fish are doing great. I would think it had something to do with "aclimate the fish"
 
I have bought fish there before and inverts...no prob.
BUT I knew the risk, and I would never recommend to anyone to buy livestock from there.
 
thats the first thing i have that died from there but i dislike the service sometimes, usually cause most of them dont know anything... example..
i went in there before i thought about doing corals to ask about the flow i needed for a SPS tank and they told me 2 - 3x the turnover rate of the tank... for my tank that would be 60-90 gph of flow.. yeah right...

i drip aclimate everything that goes into the tank so i know it wasnt that. i just think i need to check out other stores. i looked at age of aquarium last night and want impressed.. maybe becuase it was right after thanksgiving.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=11251006#post11251006 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Chef Reef
thats the first thing i have that died from there but i dislike the service sometimes, usually cause most of them dont know anything... example..
i went in there before i thought about doing corals to ask about the flow i needed for a SPS tank and they told me 2 - 3x the turnover rate of the tank... for my tank that would be 60-90 gph of flow.. yeah right...

i drip aclimate everything that goes into the tank so i know it wasnt that. i just think i need to check out other stores. i looked at age of aquarium last night and want impressed.. maybe becuase it was right after thanksgiving.

Talk to Steve
 
that usually who i talk to, he seems to know the most out of everybody there. if he's not around i talk to the guy with the strong accent that usually has spiky hair. (forgot his name)
 
Chef Reef......you live close to Fishes Of Eden. Have you ever been there.? Great customer service healthy fish, far prices
Brian
 
guys fish die - its part of their life cycle, every store has them fish that is, Its up to the customer to choose.
 
you also have to remember, your moving from one tank to another. New surrounding Stress water conditions etc. This is why they put a Guarantee on fish.
 
Every time i go to age of aquarium most of their fish have ick. I would deff check out Fishes of Eden and if its not to far for you CRF.
 
The fish that I got did not go into the new tank. It went into a very well established (5-6 years) QT tank. There are no meds in it yet. I wanted to watch him for a while. I always acclimate them very slowly.
This is the first time that I bought fish there. I saw there Holiday sales flyer, so I went to check it out. Steve was not there when I was there and nobody told me to buy them in pairs.
It did not come directly out of the bag. I saw those signs. I would never buy directly from the bag either.
Live and learn!
 
i only post negative info about that i just post negative experiances. i have nothing again beverly's.

thats for Fishes of Eden info, i headr about it before but i couldnt remember the name of the store and was trying to find it yesterday
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=11251461#post11251461 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Chef Reef
i only post negative info about that i just post negative experiances. i have nothing again beverly's.

thats for Fishes of Eden info, i headr about it before but i couldnt remember the name of the store and was trying to find it yesterday
Fishes of Eden
 
gasman, I'd like to believe that, but I've been reefing and Fish Only-ing since I was around 12. Beverly's has been around for as long as I can remember, I used to go there when it was on the NORTHEAST corner, before they moved to the SOUTHWEST corner of Pines and Univ. First the positive, I agree, Steve is the most knowledgeable guy I've ever dealt with. That being said, I haven't talked to him in around 6 years when he really ticked me off. I had a show quality Salvinia cichlid that he said go ahead and bring in, we'll give you store credit for it... I was setting up a saltwater tank and was planning on spending around $1000 for the stuff to get it going. We came in, he acclimated the fish and dumped him in (way too soon) and said, okay, we'll give you $2 for it. I paid around $15 2 years before for a tiny fish, and this guy was much bigger (around 3"). He had done this for me a couple of years before that, with a huge oscar and pacu that had outgrown my tank, and they'd made me happy with that store credit.

Finally, I agree with the quality of fish, I've had around a 50% mortality rate from them. Haven't bought a fish since.... that's how I deal with poor quality. I still buy the occasional drygoods from them.
 
Back
Top