Did your tank stay the way you designed it?

Sk8r

Staff member
RC Mod
White doesn't last long. White rock is dead. Live rock isn't white. Ditto sand. It generally just doesn't stay white, except sand. Sand can do better at it, but face it, life may get there, too.

Did your rock stay where you intended? I've never had a rock-slide. I use eggcrate lighting grid under my rockwork to prevent that. But do I have to move a rock to deal with something? Oh, yes.

Did what I wanted to grow work? Well, up to a point, but tanks differ, and sometimes it's a good idea to throw into the towel and admit THIS build wants to grow something else more than it wants to grow what you intended.

This doesn't mean failure. It means that the complex ecosystem you established is a) alive, we hope and b) has the capability to favor SOMETHING. Now if this turns out to be flatworms or aiptasia, you have to take some action. But generally, don't beat yourself up or declare failure if your tank is taking a different path than you planned. If it's a decent direction, go with it. Admit this isn't a good wrasse tank, or a good sps tank or whatever. It's not failure, but a step along the way; and maturity may send it in yet another direction. Surprise! it's an lps tank, or a great softie tank, or whatever.

In something so complex, it takes experience to aim and hit the exact thing you were going for. Count it 'gaining experience,' and go by the 'numbers' we give you to start, which will hopefully land you a good tank for something you have yet to discover. Research life requirements. Match the fish and corals you buy to the tank you have, not vice versa, for reasons of, yes, having it stay alive. Start simple, work up. 'Rare' isn't precious, it means something that has trouble living in our tanks or that reproduces terribly slowly. But when we say 'invasive'...that means it REALLY grows like mad, and keep it on a rock you can dispose of: keep it from taking a structural rock. But if you have a fish-only, an 'invasive' may actually outgrow predation...so it's not utterly a bad thing.

Ultimately you get the experience that will let you plan a tank that actually works out, but I'll guarantee you the most experienced of reefers STILL gets surprised as a tank develops. Serendipity rules this hobby more than most. Hesitate to destroy unscheduled specimens, but if you get a chance, and it's scary-looking, nab it, put it in a bowl, and photograph it and post it: we'll tell you whether to put it into your tank or down into your sump. Or not.
 
I have always started out with a plan in mind, but because it is a living, breathing entity in it's own right, it will become what it wants to become. Sure, you can steer it in a given direction, but it will evolve into whatever it is destined to be.

Case in point:

In about 1988, I bought a Oceanic 150 long (72x24x21) with the intention of it become a killer reef. Long wide, and (relatively) shallow. About 1 month later, my GF (the LFS owner) convinced me to take home an 18" Eel that came in. Hannibal lived in that tank for the next 25 years, mostly by himself (note his name). When he (finally) died, I just didn't have the place or desire to convert the tank to a reef - I already had a 120 SPS reef doing very well, so I sold the tank and converted part of the area it took up into a frag tank so that I had someplace for all the trimmings from the 120.

Do I regret any of that? Nope - it became what it was supposed to become, regardless of whatever it was I wanted for it.

Life can be that way!
 
Mine does not look like what I first thought it would be. It has evolved and continues to evolve mostly due to my changing tastes. For about a year or so, I have become infatuated with Gorgonians. Fish wise I have mostly wrasses now, compared to when I first started up my current tank and wanted mostly tangs.
 
Not really.

Oh, the corals in my tank are the ones I started with, but the liverock's been picked up and put down a few times - and it never seems to wind up exactly the way it was. The fish are, by and large, the ones I originally planned - even though I had to purchase more than I'd have liked to twice, due to ich, jumping, QT issues . . . :'-(

I've got a feeling that my little 65gallon system is about to change again . . .

There's a 220 gallon glass box sitting next to it.

~Bruce
 
Case in point:

In about 1988, I bought a Oceanic 150 long (72x24x21) with the intention of it become a killer reef. Long wide, and (relatively) shallow. About 1 month later, my GF (the LFS owner) convinced me to take home an 18" Eel that came in. Hannibal lived in that tank for the next 25 years, mostly by himself (note his name). When he (finally) died, I just didn't have the place or desire to convert the tank to a reef - I already had a 120 SPS reef doing very well, so I sold the tank and converted part of the area it took up into a frag tank so that I had someplace for all the trimmings from the 120.

Do I regret any of that? Nope - it became what it was supposed to become, regardless of whatever it was I wanted for it.

Life can be that way!

I had that same tank in the early 90s, those were good tanks!

Moving them sucked.
 
Back
Top