Dying Stonies

I've seen something sort of like this on a Porites, but the speed of recession was slower and the line of recession was more distinct. I also did not see any tissue slough off. I tried cutting the coral up well ahead of the recession line but was not able to stop it. During the year or so I was fighting it on the Porites I did not see it obviously spread to the few Acro, Stylos, Pocs, Montis or Birdsnest in the same tank.

Eric B. guessed UV damage as a outer jacket on a mogul bulb had broken some weeks earlier and burnt or bleached most of the SPS in the tank before I noticed, especially those higher up. But the Porites was at the bottom and showed no sign of damage right after. He said that it was possible for the coral to go a while before showing damage. But the recession continued from the more light and current exposed branches down onto the base of the coral. Maybe the UV damage start it but something else make it continue.

I'd be inclined to remove a coral just starting to show symptoms from the tank and try the antibiotic protocal suggested by Craig Bingham. In the system some change in husbandry to get nitrate and P down may help, IMHO. I'd be spooky about using organic carbon source (acetic acid, sugar, vodka) to get nitrate down but you have the powerful skimmer if a bloom breaks out and frankly at this point I don't see what you have to loose. Wish I could offer something more substantive or helpful.
 
From my understanding, everytime you do a water change you are introducing silicates into your system. It doesn't matter if you using RO/DI, ALL salt mixes have silicates in them. So, that may be where your diatom, and cyno is coming from. But every 4 or 5 days doesn't seem like you have a "problem".

Anyways, sorry to hear, and i agree that water parameters are good. Something is eating these things. There are people you could hire who WILL figure this out for you. Getting them to get there before everything is already dead is a different story. But, never the less you could give it a shot. Hire a qualified person to come over and pinpoint the problem.
 
KK- your corals were doing fine for quite some time before they went south. What was your water change schedule like before all of this started?
 
Well guys, an update: my corals are growing again!

This past week several of them started re-growing tissue.

I feel fairly confident that the cause of all of this was something from the home-made seafood medley I had been feeding.

The first time this started (months ago) I did many W/C's, ran GFO, carbon, poly filters, etc... and nothing changed, BUT, I was still feeding that food.

I waited about a month, then made this OP, and started doing everything over again -- lots of W/C's, GFO, etc., but this time, I stopped feeding that food, and stuck to known things like Hikari enriched mysis. Now the corals are bouncing back.

I do not know what was in that food, but for a rare treat in this hobby, I feel fairly confident it caused this odd recession.

I can finally begin the rebuilding process and plan to purchase some corals starting immediately! :)

In the process, I did install a RDSB;
a24-rdsb2.jpg


and do plan to continue to run small amounts of GFO. The AWT tests showed I could use a little reduction in both nitrates and phosphates.

Thanks everyone for your support and suggestions.
 
I need to take a picture of the packaging from the super market (havent been able to find it online), but I believe its called "Seafood Medley", and it is frozen raw seafood sold in a bag at Publix supermarkets.

I used a small food processor, and minced it up with RO/DI, PE Mysis, and Cyclopeeze. That's it.
 
Very interesting. I wonder if it had some kind of nasty preservative in it.


Thanks for the update and I'm glad your corals are doing better. :)
 
Back
Top