The wife and I went to Cincinnati a couple weeks ago. We were impressed by a place called Monfort Aquarium & Pet Shop, 6520 Colerain Ave., Cincinnati, Ohio, 45239; Phone: 513-923-3369. You can cut and paste that address and get directions from Mapquest.
The guy running the place is named Tom Schulze, and he used to sell stuff to Fuji before Fuji got his own shop. Tell Tom you're from WV, and that you know Fuji - he'll get a kick out of it.
BTW - Monfort's has a Bubble tip anemone the size of a bowling ball. I'm not kidding. He's had it since, I believe, 1989. A pair of clowns breed under it on a regular basis. It looks like a scene out of Finding Nemo.
They also have a frogspawn coral you won't believe. Everything they have is big and healthy, and he's low-tech all the way.
I won't say anything about Monfort's pricing on their livestock and dry goods, but you'd be smart to take some cash with you. Go there and you'll see what I mean.