Haddoni & Gigantea in same tank?

[RoastReef]

Has anybody successfully kept a Haddoni and a Gigantea in the same tank? I know it's not recommended, just wondering if anybody has done it.

 

[taylor t]

I've done it. Mine touched and had no reaction between the two flopping on each other.

 

[cichlidconvert]

Sorry to bring up an old thread but its what I want to know

I've done it. Mine touched and had no reaction between the two flopping on each other.

Has anyone else experienced the same results?

 

[DogueDeBordeaux]

I would be interested knowing some info on this.
How many has had problems though? I have a very healthy gig, and would not want to cause any problems for it.

 

[God.]

I am keeping 2 rbta 2 gigantea 1 haddoni and 1 h. Crispa in a 240 dt. 96 x 24 x 30 I believe. I run 2 tlf phosban reactors full of carbon with an asm g-4+ skimmer.

Rbta and gigs have been together for about 6 months no ill effect. Haddoni added 2 months ago no ill effect. H crispa added last week. So far no ill effects. Well see how it plays out.

On a side note I had one gig get whooped by a colony of galaxia. No sign of infection though.

 

[cichlidconvert]

Well I have gigs and haddoni in the same tank. I was wondering if anyone had them touching with or without effect.

 

[OrionN]

I got Gigantea, Haddoni and Malu in the same tank without problem.

 

[DogueDeBordeaux]

For those with the multiple anemones do you have more than one pair of clowns in the same tank with anemones?

If I have onyx percs in a gig, and add a haddoni could I safetly add some pink or orange skunks for the haddoni? The anemones would be atleast 4ft apart.

 

[Deepsea2005]

I don't have them in the same tank but in the same 600g system for about a year now.
The blue gig in a 300g tank, and a red haddoni in a 150g tank.