I have tried kalk, peppermint shrimp, naso, angels, pencil urchin, limpets, crabs. All to no avail. I have five tangs in my tank, two dwarf angels, foxface, two pencil urchins, limpets, carbs, and snails, none of them will touch this stuff. I had about ten peppermint shrimp in the tank that didn't touch them, but in all fairness, they didn't have much time to work since my flame hawk found them tasty. This stuff is a curse. I am going to remove the effected rock, but i have the stuff growing on the back walls of the tank. I haven't figured out how to get rid of those yet.