Is Chromis aggressive?

AquaWave523

New member
I heard the Chromis is less aggressive than their counterpart cousins Damsels?

When referring to damsel fish to cycle a tank, is it the same as Chromis or Damsel?

I guess I'm confused if they are the same thing? I wanted to get a school of them when my tank is finish cycling but i dont want to put them in first if they are territorial and mean.
 
Chromis are peaceful and not aggressive like damsels... I think they need a lot of flow to school though. Otherwise they will just keep picking off members of the school until they are down to a pair.

I'm sure someone will correct me if I'm mistaken :p
 
Chromis and damsels are related, but not the same thing.

In my experience, chromis are pretty peaceful toward other species of fish, but not as friendly among themselves.

From what I've read, it seems that schooling behavior is most likely when they're sharing a tank with something pretty large, that they consider a threat. My experience, which I've seen repeated in these boards many times, is that a group of six or eight does not school, the dominant chromis pick on the weaker ones, and eventually they whittle themselves down to one or two survivors.
Edit: Interestingly, the article referenced in a previous post suggests the opposite: that large, threatening fish will make chromis more likely to disperse and hide, rather than school.

Don't get me wrong. I like blue-green chromis. I just wouldn't put more than 2 in a tank together.

The idea of cycling a tank with a damsel (or any fish) seems to be a holdover from the old days when people didn't use live rock and live sand. The fish was the source of the bacteria that set up the nitrogen cycle. Now, you can get all the bacteria you need to start the cycle from live rock. Add a cup of sand from an established tank and some plain aragonite sand, and you're set.

Aside from the cruelty to animals aspect, advising anyone to cycle with a damsel is my idea of cruelty to reefkeepers. Once a fish gets into a reef tank, it's harder than you might expect to get it back out. Some people have reported removing every piece of live rock, just to catch one fish. Unfortunately, many damsels are so territorial (nice word for vicious) that removing them is necessary if you're going to keep other fishes in the tank.

Skip the damsel. Don't cycle with a chromis, either. If you don't trust the live rock to produce enough ammonia, add one uncooked coctail shrimp to the tank. Really, for most people, even that's not required.

Live rock comes with lots of critters on and inside it. When the rock goes into a brand-new tank, some of those critters will die and begin producing ammonia. Bacteria from the rock will start eating the ammonia. Days to weeks later, you have a cycled tank.
 
Last edited:
Very nice post "KarlBob" pretty much what I would have said, but have a feeling that you said it a lot better.

In the last 10 years I cycled my tanks with just live rock, and they all turned out great. I even do water changes during the cycle to limit the ammonia spike -- to help preserve as much of the "life" on the live rock that I paid good money for.
 
Thank you. I think you'd have done fine, but glad to have been of service. I'm also glad to see a testimonial for live-rock-only cycling. Having someone say it's theoretically possible is just not as persuasive as someone saying "I've done this, and it worked for me".
 
+ 1 to the above.

Dont use a fish to cycle, throwing a pinch of food every now and then is just as good.

I strongly advise against a damsel or chromis. Both can be aggressive and a PITA, and you'lll have a heck of a time trying to get them out!
 
Something is going to die, one way or the other. Whether it's a damsel, the cooked shrimp that gave it's life for the cause, or the life within the rock that will have to withstand the perils of a cycle.

That's how I see it.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=15333337#post15333337 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by cloak
Something is going to die, one way or the other. Whether it's a damsel, the cooked shrimp that gave it's life for the cause, or the life within the rock that will have to withstand the perils of a cycle..

See the thread about shrimp. IF you're going to use them, it's better to use raw. In addition, even that is unnecessary. LR will have enough die-off on its own to create a nice cycle. If you're not using LR, just start feeding the tank as if there were fish in it, since that will also get your cycle going. This way, nothing has to die.
 
Most likely if you get a school of chromis then chances are that all are going to die except 2. I had 6 chromis in my tank and all died except 2.

These fish are not aggressive at all. When I first started with saltwater I had the yellow-tailed damsels and I had 2 orange clowns and the damsels killed the clowns.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=15336752#post15336752 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by bluetanggirl
Most likely if you get a school of chromis then chances are that all are going to die except 2. I had 6 chromis in my tank and all died except 2.

That's a very common experience. Chromis often whittle down their numbers to 1 or 2, no matter how many you start out with (and that's true for odd and even number of fish).
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=15336643#post15336643 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Wolverine
See the thread about shrimp. IF you're going to use them, it's better to use raw. In addition, even that is unnecessary. LR will have enough die-off on its own to create a nice cycle. If you're not using LR, just start feeding the tank as if there were fish in it, since that will also get your cycle going. This way, nothing has to die.

I'm not exactly sure you understood my post. No worries though.

:)
 
I have had 3 chromis in my tank for about 9 months now. The big one is the leader, but has never gone after any of my other fish in the tank. Once in a great while, he will go after the smallest chromis, but not all the time. I would also use the liverock for my cycling and never had a problem with it!
 
Note that not all chromis are created equal, either. Like any other genus of animals, some are more peaceful than others.
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=15338963#post15338963 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Elysia
Note that not all chromis are created equal, either. Like any other genus of animals, some are more peaceful than others.

Exactly, and same holds true with damsels.
 
I know it's an old thread, but I've found that when a chromis gets large they can start to become territorial. I had a green chromis that I had to get rid of because he'd swim back and forth in the tank and shoo everyone else into the liverock.
 
So a super old thread hopefully some see's this. I Had my Madagascar Tiger tailed Coral Beauty die yesterday. And since then my Green Chromi has been Attacking my Clownfish. I think Zeeter was on to something. When they are small had mine since it was 1/2 an inch and now is 1 1/2 an inch. the coral beauty died and was the biggest in my tank. My Clownfish followed the angel and i think it was because the clown might have been picked on by the chromi at some point. The chromi is in a breeder box for the night and going back to the LFS first thing in the morning. After watching it ram my Clown into the glass. Its lucky it isnt being flushed.
 
Chromis are heartily disliked by dascyllus damsels, and chromis don't like other chromis much, either. They school, but they pick off the weakest of the group nightly if there aren't enough separate sleeping spots.
 
Chromis are heartily disliked by dascyllus damsels, and chromis don't like other chromis much, either. They school, but they pick off the weakest of the group .

This. Also chromis are highly susceptible to uronema.
 
I had a pair of green chromis for several years. They grew to a little over three inches so they can get relatively big. In my experience they are hardy and very territorial. Mine would also knock anything off the rockwork that wasn't glued down. They got along well with clowns but that was about it.
 
Back
Top