Magnesium

121

Member
My Mg is 1200 according to my hobby/toy test kit :jester:

Iirc, Mg naturally forms a compound with chloride to make MgCl2. When Mg is low, what happens to the free chloride? Does it form a new compound with something else?

If so, will this new chloride compound reverse back to MgCl2 if I slowly dosed MgO?
 
The chloride and the magnesium part ways as soon as you put it into the water. After that, they don't have much to do with one another. Both will exist as a free ion. Use MgCl2 or MgSO4 to raise your mag back up.
 
I'm slowly dosing MgO which doesn't add additional chlorides and sulfates. Are you sure Mg and Cl don't have much to do with each other? I thought Mg and Cl made the abundant MgCl2 compound. Please correct me if I'm wrong.
 
Last edited:
You have a basic misunderstanding of how salts work in solution.

When you dissolve MgCl2 in water, the Mg2+ and Cl- ions part ways. In solution there is no such thing as MgCl2. It dissolves. There are Mg2+ ions and there are Cl- ions and they are all surrounded by water and spread out and really don't interact much anymore. If you were to evaporate salt water and crystalize all of the salt, you still wouldn't find MgCl2. The magnesium will come out with hydroxide and carbonate, because Mg(OH)2 and MgCO3 are much less soluble than MgCl2. So they will precipitate at a Mg2+ concentration where MgCl2 is still soluble.

That solubility thing is the reason we use MgCl2 to dose back the magnesium. And why we use CaCl2 to dose calcium. You can put a lot more magnesium in the same amount of water because MgCl2 is way more soluble than MgO or MgCO3, especially at pH higher than 7.

The concentration of chloride ion in your salt water is so much higher than the amount that you are adding when you dose with MgCl2 that the added chloride really has little effect. In Randy's DIY 2-part article there is a discussion of using epsom salts as a less expensive source of magnesium. In it there is discussion of the relative concentrations of sulfate and chloride and the proper balance to maintain.

So the take home message is this. It doesn't matter what two ions you add together, so long as you realize you are adding both. Adding MgCl2 and Na2CO3, is equivalent to adding MgCO3 and NaCl. Except that you would need low pH to dissolve the MgCO3.
 
So the real answer to your first question. What happens to the chloride when Mg gets low?

It just keeps on floating around, not hooked up to anything, and never notices that the Mg left.
 
This might help to think about too.

Using MgO adds alkalinity. 2 equivalents for every equivalent of Mg.

Oxide doesn't dissolve in water, it reacts with water to make hydroxide. The O takes a proton from a water molecule to make OH- (1 equivalent) and that leaves behind an OH- from the water molecule (the other equivalent).

If you dissolved it in acid, it would get an acid proton (equivalent to adding one OH-) and make one OH- out of the oxide.
 
Back
Top