Malu/Crispa? ID Help

Silfer

Gonnae no dae that.
So i'm looking for a true Malu and a shop here has this one, said I can post the pic to get help ID'n it, he said if I need any other info just ask. He said it has an orange foot:

223_zps50e70714.jpg


Thanks
 
I'm saying Malu but not 100% I have kept crispa before but never Malu.

Orange foot could be dyed. As I bought a crispa one time with dyed foot.
I like the Malu myself but I don't have the sand bed for them.
Lets see if others can chime in.
 
If it is a malu, i'd jump on it.

Just wondering but can the whole anemone be dyed? How can you tell if they're dyed or not?

I'm waiting for an malu that looks like this.

020207-356.jpg
 
Its really hard to tell from the picture. It's not always easy to tell in person, because a stressed crispa looks a lot like a malu.

From the apparent size and the way it is holding itself, my guess would be crispa. If the foot is actually orange, that would swing me in the direction of malu.
 
Well I've reserved it. Guess I'll find out for sure on Tuesday as its getting posted to me on Monday!

I hope it fairs well in transit.
 
He said the foot is orange, I think the picture makes it look bigger than it is.

Will update Tuesday. If it is a Crispa I'll let it settle and sell it on as its a malu I want.
 
If it is a Crispa I'll let it settle and sell it on as its a malu I want.

I'm curious, why would you want to sell it if it's a crispa? (It's a beaut!) I have a crispa, I bought as a malu. I thought for years it was a malu, and some on here after I posted a picture, told me it's a crispa. It's about 8" on a good day. Small tents at the mouth, longer ones at the rim. I feed it a few times a week and have had it for a few years. Do you want to sell it because of the size they claim they get? Mine doesn't get very big. What ever you choose, best wishes! :)
 
Size and the fact crispa will happily go up onto the rocks. Whereas malus will stay on the sand.
 
It is really hard to tell as is. Once healthy and in it stable environment it is easier. Right now it can be either. If it is larger than 4-5 in in that picture (which will get a lot larger once it expand to normal size) then it is much more likely to be a Crispa. If it is small than it can be either.
Once healthy, I am sure Phil can tell. I can take a stab at it once it is healthy and be right most of the time.
 
couple pics the seller sent me, hope it will be okay being shipped tomorrow as the mouth is open:

IMG_1543_zpsdb414a4d.jpg


IMG_1544_zps474c3b79.jpg
 
That would be awesome, because in 5 years of keeping marines I've only ever seen one other malu for sale here. Certainly not one of this colour.
 
Well, I put it by the rock on the sand.. it moved onto the rock and has tucked itself in under a rock overhang. Not sure if it's a Malu or Crispa as it's not in the sand at all.. tentacles are short (about 1cm), maybe my lights were too much for it.

It isn't losing any colour or gaping mouth:

IMG_1647_zps008a0bfe.jpg
 
Regardless of what it is that's a nice looking nem. I would be concerned about your lighting being too much.

Fwiw...............my red malu has a white foot and it stopped growing at about 6-7 inches. It would never sit still unless the base was touching sand, but I imagine if the light is too much it's not going to care about sand & do whatever it a can to avoid too much light intensity.
 
It looks healthy in that last shot, but that is too dark for it to stay, I expect. I'm thinking malu, too, but a good pic once it is all settled in should make id easier.
 
Back
Top