Maroon vs. Percula??

kaserpick

Keeping it Simple
I know this is not a good idea, but I wanted to ask:

1. Will a maroon clown get along with a percula clown?

2. Is a sixline wrasse, maroon clown and percula too many fish for a 30 gal??

Thanks for the help guys; I think I already know the answers.
 
The maroon will kill the percula.
The sixline would probably be ok with either, but not with both.
HTH,
Mariner
 
Maroons have reputation as being mean. I have a maroon clown in my 135 and she can be real mean, exspecially if another fish or my hand gets near her BTA. Also they get pretty big and in a few years would look like a whale in a swimming pool in a 30 gal tank.

I would say stick with the perc, six line and some kind of blenny, dottyback or other small fish. IMO 3's the limit but when it comes to fish but I am a firm believer in less is better. Less fish= less stress on the tanks biological system, which= happy tank.
 
I'm right there with you Dean. Currently I only have two the sixline and the perc., but it took me about 8 months to finally put the perc in the tank. I wanted to make sure the system was set and then keep a light bio load. Thanks for the info guys!
 
This isn't always true for 2 clowns of mixed species, but 2 juvenile clowns will fight, and fight, and fight (this is not to be misunderstood as courtship) until the dominate one changes sex and becomes a female.

It's called protogynous hermaphrodytism, spelling?
All clowns of all species start out as males and when two juvenile clowns are placed in one tank they duke it out until one becomes a domineering, larger, female.

You should be aware of this when you put two clowns together because they need lots of space for fighting and they should have a lid on the tank in case they jump while doing this.

If you want two clowns in the same tank it's much better if you buy two that have already been paired this way. :mixed:
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=8941572#post8941572 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by the cattleman
This isn't always true for 2 clowns of mixed species, but 2 juvenile clowns will fight, and fight, and fight (this is not to be misunderstood as courtship) until the dominate one changes sex and becomes a female.

It's called protogynous hermaphrodytism, spelling?
All clowns of all species start out as males and when two juvenile clowns are placed in one tank they duke it out until one becomes a domineering, larger, female.

You should be aware of this when you put two clowns together because they need lots of space for fighting and they should have a lid on the tank in case they jump while doing this.

If you want two clowns in the same tank it's much better if you buy two that have already been paired this way. :mixed:

I would agree with you on this point

But ultimitly not matter what IMO a Maroon clown is just to much fish for a 30 gal tank once it matures. Now you could get away with it for a while but eventually you will need to move it to a bigger system.

By the way I do love my Maroon clown and IMO a very attractive fish. But she is not afraid of anything including me.

You see every fish in my 135 in this photo except my six line wrasse. don't let the Green Chromis foul you it is right up front This picture gives you no idea how big the Tang and Clown are.

17434DSC00659.jpg
 
i thought clowns were Asexual...or without sex until such a point they see it fit to become one or the other, via fighting or loss of a dominant female....or is that only with a school of clowns..

anyway i thought i read that some where here..

either way the maroon is a bully for sure...
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=8945175#post8945175 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by NanoReefWanabe
i thought clowns were Asexual...or without sex until such a point they see it fit to become one or the other, via fighting or loss of a dominant female....or is that only with a school of clowns..

anyway i thought i read that some where here..

either way the maroon is a bully for sure...

I believe you are correct on the Asexual quote.

Sorry I guess its a guy thing when I called my clown a she. It has never had a mate so I would assume it is a IT!:eek1:
 
<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=8947922#post8947922 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by kkyyllee
it might be a she though since its the dominant one since there are no others
That's a good question. I don't know if a clown all by itself in a tank will become a female since there's no others. In other words it will get big and mature.

On the other hand, the fighting process might be what triggers the sex change.

I'll have to look it up in my Clownfishes book.
 
A clown alone in a tank will become dominante as a female. With no challenge it will just become female. It says so in the paring clownfish thread, in the clownfish and anenomes forums.
 
Back
Top