Maturity Issues

John,

I think your situation is common and without any answers which will improve both your tank and the other family members opinions.

I have to keep some fish in my reef which I would prefer to omit. With all the time and community property I spend on this I feel I must compromise.

If you introduce the carnivores or herbivores you know what they'll eat so you just have to decide which you want to put at risk.

Steve U
 
I think a 50 gallon tank is kind of small for most if not all surgenfishes, but herbivorous blennies are a good choice.
 
Eric, you said that corals would be helpful if they're the one's that would be tolerant of tank conditions. What kinds of corals are you refering to.
 
All I can say is WOW! This thread has become the most informative I have seen on RC in regards to the evolution of our captive systems. I truly wish I would have had access to this info when I started with my system. I would also like to know what type of corals would be the appropriate "first corals" to go into our tanks. Thank you again Mr. Borneman for all the info!!!!
 
All I can say is WOW! This thread has become the most informative I have seen on RC in regards to the evolution of our captive systems. I truly wish I would have had access to this info when I started with my system. I would also like to know what type of corals would be the appropriate "first corals" to go into our tanks. Thank you again Mr. Borneman for all the info!!!!
 
All I can say is WOW! This thread has become the most informative I have seen on RC in regards to the evolution of our captive systems. I truly wish I would have had access to this info when I started with my system. I would also like to know what type of corals would be the appropriate "first corals" to go into our tanks. Thank you again Mr. Borneman for all the info!!!!
 
I would also like to know what type of corals would be the appropriate "first corals" to go into our tanks.
Click to expand...

He already said that it depends on the individual tank.

Which will be helpful in a 10 gallon tank?
Also a 40 gallon tank?
Click to expand...

Size is far from the only condition in something like this.
 
Thanks so much for all the info! I started researching this website after two of my fish died, in a new tank (about a month old), and am now beginning to understand it a bit more. Will still have plenty of questions but am bookmarking this page to come back and re-read. Thanks, again!
Shelly
 
Eric, you said that corals would be helpful if they're the one's that would be tolerant of tank conditions. What kinds of corals are you refering to.
Click to expand...

Don't mean to resurect a dead post, but this thread has been really helpful. If you have the time to answer, i'd appreciate clarification of this point. Does the answer to this question have more to do with something like export of nutrients, or with outcompeting specific algae or some other organic nuisance? or both? or neither?

Also, how much does hobbiest experience and system planning (i.e. someone wanting a SPS tank v. a low-light biotope focused on corrallines and deepwater Anithias) factor into an answer?

I'm sorry if this question is too general, and it can't be answered reasonably well as is. But, I've enjoyed the curing process of my LR and the aftermath much more than I anticipated (my friends think I'm crazy when I get excited about seeing such ugly things as Amphipods crawling arond my LR), and I've really become more interested in the growth of my tank than I'd ever have thought.

Thanks.
 
Six to eight month syndrome?

Six to eight month syndrome?

Has anyone experienced this? After getting a reef tank established for a few months, things get settled in, grow, expand, divide, look great; then six to eight months into this success, things don't expand like they did, shrink and just fade away. No crash, just a gradual atrophy.

Thanks for the ongoing discussion.

C.J. S.
 
Re: Six to eight month syndrome?

Re: Six to eight month syndrome?

pelagic said:
Has anyone experienced this? After getting a reef tank established for a few months, things get settled in, grow, expand, divide, look great; then six to eight months into this success, things don't expand like they did, shrink and just fade away. No crash, just a gradual atrophy.
C.J. S.
Click to expand...

Can you give some more specific information:

- What specifically is shrinking/fading away?
- What kind of animals/fish/coral do you have, and when did you add them?
- What are your tank specifics, ie. size, lighting, skimmer, sand, LR, etc.?
- How often (and how much) do you do water changes and feeding?
- Have you run any tests on the water?
 
Last edited:
Pelagic I have the same question. I have a system that has been set up for two years (actually a six year old system that was moved two years ago) and has been incredibly healthy until recently. Things arent expanding as they were, and one group of ricordia (I had four years) just shrivled up and wasted away. I have been doing water changes weekly (was doing monthly ones prior) as something seems to be affecting the system. Even my 6 year old hammer is not expanding as it did and my rose BTA has decided to start roaming around the tank.
I am at a loss. My test kits are old so I am going to get new ones and run a boat load of tests but I cannot figure out what is wrong.
One thing...About the same time that all of this started I also noticed the appearance of what looks like a small patch of black/green cyano. I have never seen this in my system before and as much as I try to clean it up it comes right back (although it never gets larger than a 2 inch patch). My system is a 100 gal with 30 gal sump. Lighting is 2 400w radiums and it is being skimmed by a euro reef 8-2. As far as corals go its got a little bit of everything from my basketball sized hammer to a couple acros and even the Tyree green polyp leather.
Any information would be greatly appreciated.
-Ian
 
I think my brain just went numb. I am finally getting a better understanding of my tanks. I set up a 10 gal. LR tank about 6 months ago and am amazed at the life running around on the rock. I've put no fish in, only a few snails and hermits. Since the LR seems to be teaming with so much more life than my display tank, I swap out rocks from time to time (i.e. "intermediate disturbance". I always thought of it as kind of a re-fueling of the rock. Since I began doing this I've noticed a dramatic increase in both the growth of my existing corals and a great reduction in the death of my fish and corals. I realize this also has to do with the maturity of me and my tank. Thanks Eric for your time. I feel like I can finally see the forest despite the trees.
TOM
 
I think I understand now what Eric is trying to get across. In my haste and excitement after reading this thread I foolishly thought that there was the "perfect" mix of corals that would go into our tank to provide that utopian habitat we are all striving for. I know now that that is far from feasible with the limited amount of reasources we are provided with at our LFS or even from online stores. We can only look to re-create a very small slice of the reefs that we know. To think that there is such a diversity on the reefs that if we tried to duplicate it we would fail miserably is very humbling.

One thing I think we might have to take into consideration is the fact that we might have to go "DSB-less" GASP! to be able to maintain a really nutrient poor system for those precious Acros and Montis and other "clean" water corals OR on the flip side possibly setup a "mangrove" type system with the DSB to keep our soft corals such as the 'shrooms and various other "dirty water" corallimorphs that require higher nutrient levels to survive. Reason I say all of that is because of the experiences I have seen other hobbyists go through in trying to keep a "mixed" system with both "dirty" water and "clean" water corals and the horrific results that are obtained i.e. shrooms and rics and other softies dying when a new, more powerful skimmer is introduced or that new Tunze stream shooting out 3000 gph blowing the crap outta everything. I think we need to rethink the whole DSB thing and apply it to our particular situation or habitat that we are trying to recreate, I mean I am only thinking about what I have seen and read over and over again and am only repeating the observations that I have made.

Then again I might be totally and completely off and might as well go stick this where the sun don't shine! :D
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

P
Cycling Questions
Replies
7
Views
393
SantaMonica
S
M
Random GSP Closure. Ideas?
Replies
6
Views
183
griss
griss
305 Steve
Steve's Reef Casa
Replies
10
Views
380
305 Steve
305 Steve
hrdneglcry
Why can't I grow coral?
Replies
3
Views
91
Reefing102
Reefing102
JCOLE
Does anyone have any established sand/rock they can spare?
Replies
5
Views
217
Reefing102
Reefing102
Back
Top