multiple haddoni carpets dedicated aquarium

Well I know some have ripped you for doing this and said the success rate is minimal blah, blah blah. The bottomline is that it proves it can be done and just knowing that should open up the area for more research. I think the fact it can be done would lend itself to the possibility that this practice can eventually be perfected on a sustainable level. There was a time when people didn't even think keeping anemones and other inverts was a possibility. Over time and lots of dead animals later experienced hobbyists can create systems that can sustain multitudes of organisms. 2 thumbs up from me and hopefully we can go from a 50% rate of survival to 75% and eventually on up to near 100%.
 
Jadran the haddoni won't eat or you just don't try to feed? In 7 months it seems like it would be eating. I had mags that divided on their own, it took a few weeks, but after they they were able to take small foods, as I recall. I didn't read the whole thread, but has the frag been increasing in diameter without target feeding? Definitely interesting thread and project you have going.
 
<b>Well I know some have ripped you for doing this and said the success rate is minimal blah, blah blah.</b>
:) Yeah, not really ripped, preached or lectured is more like it but its ok for it is done before to me (dsb heresy, T5 light intensity, zeovit filtration method, keeping ritteri with corals, and so on..) with the same results.
It is widely accepted believe that you cant frag em because they do not divide in nature so their regenerative abilities were lost somewhere in time, to evolution.. When couple of seasoned anemone keepers fails to divide em and such a logical explanation arrives from some marine biologist why would even anyone disagree with the conclusion? IMO things are not so black or white, its just whole grey spectrum in between that matters. Id say THEY ARE losing their regenerative magics but didn't lost em to time just jet. Few million years from now likely but not just jet. Sure, it cant be compared with healing abilities of one entacmea quadricolor, anemonia viridis, aiptasia mutabilis or some other nem that i've been observing or dividing in quarium but still they are related. Another interesting thing would be IMO to specify the carpet anemone we talk about.. People generally talk about splitting or fragging the carpets. If its stichodactyla is it gigantea, mertensii or haddoni? First two are hard to keep alive animals, or at least it is said so. It looks to me that dividing such animal would take greater risks than doing it to one "easy to take care of" haddoni. Talking haddoni, this is not the only divided specimen with both clones surviving. There are another <b><a href="http://www.reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1470600" target="_blank">examples</a></b> of it . All together about 5 folks I came across, some here at RC, some from international forums and some from my local scene.
Still, because it take so long for them to rebuild its something for folks who are willing to devote time & space to their anemones. Coral lovers are much better off with lets say dividing BTAs.

<b>the haddoni won't eat or you just don't try to feed? In 7 months it seems like it would be eating. I had mags that divided on their own, it took a few weeks, but after they they were able to take small foods, as I recall. I didn't read the whole thread, but has the frag been increasing in diameter without target feeding?.</b>

I feed it mysids every now and then, when i feed my LPS. That seems more-or less ok, it would take a shrimp or two, nothing spectacular but still accepted. I quit giving it bigger foods after it deflated last time. That reminded me at Phill's carpet deflating after feedings so I decided not to push it towards the wrong end. Yes it grows bigger, looks to me that zooxanthellae can fulfill all iits needs at this stage. Every now and then I offer little something and observe the way it accepts it. Anyhow it cant starve so ill just wait for it to get ready.

Other experiences would be appreciated for it st clearly interesting issue, an controversial subject. Idea of dividing carpet here at RC greatly discriminated but at the same time encouraged by some of the highly respected players in the industry.
 
Have you been monitoring the nitrate level in the tank?

i have noticed that rbta's definetely will grow faster with 5ppm nitrates versus 0 ppm nitrates.
 
Hi there,
Yes Jason this is true. There is some info on that subject over at MD forums. They say anemone prop systems will benefit if nitrates are on the bit higher side. RBTAs will heal and grow faster, get better colors and basically do better in nutrient rich system. Unfortunately for my nems I dont play by these rules and take my water quality bit to serious in regards to animals i keep in there. Playing with carbon dosing filtration strategies so I'm on the wrong end on this one.
 
Thanks for your response Jardan, and best of luck with the anemone. Good to hear the anemone is growing, even without much target feeding. Please keep us posted.
 
yes, it is. Other clone lives too. Because i failed to get red and blue one I gave up idea of multiple haddons reef so i sold it to a fellow reefer. For 7 months it didn't eat so i thought to force feed it to quicken its recovery.. That wasn't needed, one day just woke up hungry. It devastated my tank: that clone captured and killed 4-5 fishes in one week time so got rid of it.
 
Those are some nice nems I recently bought a green haddoni and I'm loving it haven't gotten my clowns too host yet but I'm workin on that eventually I wanna have either a blue or red one in my tank
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I am just curious. Its seems like efforts to clone haddonis are growing although success may not be the same. glad to see your efforts made it
 
Back
Top