My experience with harlequin shrimp

Calappidae

Harlequin Shrimp
I'd thought I'd share my experience so far with harlequin shrimp. I feel they are an excellent specimen to have and many want them but are too worried about diet.. care.. tankmates.. etc.

What is a Harlequin shrimp?

First of all, if you never heard of these specimens, I should probably include what they are. Harlequin shrimp are small little shrimp that reach the size of around 1 1/2 to 2 inches in length. They appear as an odd, orchid mantis looking creature usually all white with several large blue, purple, pink, or red dots. They move around and preform a "Boxing" or "Dancing" motion as they hunt or scare off predators. They travel and form mated pairs for life. The most well know factor about these shrimp is the fact that they ONLY eat starfish... to be more specific, the tubefeet part of the starfish.

<iframe width="420" height="315" src="//www.youtube.com/embed/-DxKLIyZBKs" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
Video of a harlequin shrimp doing a defensive dance

Diet

As you read above... they ONLY will eat starfish.. this may come to surprise but believe it or not this is true. Harlequin shrimp also hunt and eat them in a very horrific way as well. First, they find their prey using scent. They will roam around searching for the starfish.. once they finally find the starfish, they will walk ontop of it to keep it scared and threatened.. thus immobilizing it. Harlequins will then attempt to flip over the starfish to expose it's tubefeet.. the only part of the star they eat. They will then drag it to their lair, and for 1 to 2 weeks, slowly pick off the tubefeet and eat... what's even more scary is the fact the harlequin may actually harvest the algae the star eats and force feed it to keep it alive! This is a very disturbing and often the reason why we frown apon this animals.

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="//www.youtube.com/embed/DAUlrIVp29g" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
A Harlequin attempting to flip over it's prey.

Naturally, first thought in your mind is these animals must have an alternative as that's a bit ridiculous... well, surprisingly there is no alternative.. there are ways to get past the whole live starfish, and the expense, but everything has to be starfish.. it is recommended to check and make sure you have an LFS (local fish store) that can easily get a supply of stars in stock at any given time as this can get really really expensive..

Methods of feeding

There are a few ways to feed them... some more humane and less expensive than others. While there are probably more out there, only 4 come to mind.

First, there is the basic method.. just feed it a live star..

Second, this is the most commonly use method. This method is mainly used for the lack of expense but is frowned apon. Setting up a starfish species aquarium, filling it up with several starfish (mainly chocolate chip), and because of their ability to regenerate lost limbs, cut a leg off of one and rotate the process cutting the leg off another star until the first one's leg has grown back. Each star also needs separated to prevent cannibalism.

The third method is the most difficult to pull off... and shouldn't be attempted even if there are millions of them. Asterina stars are a common hitchhiking pest starfish that breeds rapidly. Do note a harlequin could eat 15 in a day if it wanted to.. so a HUGE and controlled population in another species tank may work but its extremely hard to pull off.

The last and final method, which I prefer, is a frozen starfish diet. One can buy a live starfish (unless a LFS supplies them) and freeze them... the only problem with this method is the starfish rots very very quickly. Remember how I said the harlys eat a star sometimes for up to 2 weeks? They would be lucky to get 2 days out of a frozen star... feeding them smaller pieces in a daily or every other day basis is recommended to prevent too much rotting and wasting starfish.

Do note that whatever method you use to feed them.. they only eat the tubefeet part, not the actual starfish leg. The only way to tell when they are truly finished eating is if they are walking around hunting for more. Remains will have to be manually removed as most CUC (Clean-up-crews) will not bother to clean up dead rotting starfish.

Tank setup

Tank setups for harlequins are pretty simple, nothing special. One thing for sure is that they cannot tolerate moderate to high water flow... these animals are very frail and their limbs are almost like kites and will flow with the water flow sometimes. I lost 3 harlequins from the intakes of a fluval desktop filter and a 225 GPH undergravel filter powerhead. The current ones I have in my 10 gallon mini reef also struggle just from the power filter alone in there. A Protein skimmer is a very important piece of equipement as dead or rotting starfish will pollute the water quickly. They are consitured not reef safe for a few reasons.. 1. When feeding them, live stars such as chocolate chips are not reef safe.. and 2. As mentioned, they can pollute the water with their rotting starfish diet making skimmers a must have in reef setups with these. Other than those reasons, harlequins will not nip at or consume corals and are often consitured reef safe themselves.

Tank mates

Harlequin shrimp will only harass starfish, and ocassionally sea urchins. Fish such as wrasse, damsels, puffers, triggers, and invertebrates such as sally light foot crabs, arrow crabs, decorator crabs, and such are a no go with these shrimp.. Pretty much anything predatory or large should be avoided. Only one pair per tank... not only because they would need fed individually, but one of the pair's male for example might go for the other's female and they will begin fighting.

Sexing

Sexing or telling the difference between male and female is simple. Where the shrimp's pleopods are located (under the abdomen) the female will have purple large spots along the pleopods. Males will be clear and pure white under their abdomens.

This is all based off my experience.. There is a lot more valuable info that can be found here: http://www.chucksaddiction.com/harlequinshrimp.html
 
There were a few things I forgot to include...

1. Everytime I gave my harlys frozen fromia sp. stars they rejected them. Never showed interest and never ate them. (Tested with Red fromia star and red tile star)

2. I had a male elegans and a female picta. They stayed together but often seperated without hostility.
 
Great info, thanks! Have you tried breeding them?

Not yet, Harlequin breeding is very very difficult (as far as keeping the fry alive)

The young need a diet of copepods I believe, then when they gain full control of themselves, go for starfish. Its also really really hard to feed all of them as they need seperated until pairs can be identified. I think chuck, on the link I gave, might be the only harlequin breeder and he will quote multiple times that he has sever loses in fry and he never had success in raising fry to adult.

A mated pair of harlequin shrimp will breed regularly.

These shrimp are very very territoral towards other tankmates but they cannot hurt anything physically, thus they still earn the title "Harmless". Fry would somehow need seperated as harlequin shrimp will hurt other harlequin shrimp during larval stage. Even when they grow up, two or more males, and two or more females, could never be together in the same tank as one might go after the other's mate causing issues or harass and go after eachother.

Differently sexed Elegans and Elegans=pair
Differently sexed Picta and Picta=pair
Differently sexed Elegans and Picta= Not a breeding pair, may hang by each other during feeding and hunting but seperate often. (What I have now)
Same sexed harlequin shrimp= one injured, other dead, may not happen right away.
Differently sexed Hawaiian harlequin shrimp and Regular Picta= Yet to be discovered.. its unknown whether these are different species and would pair but hawaiian harlequin shrimp are said to just be a different coloration of the regular pictas that adapted to the enviroment around them.

Regular Picta
2zjjsjp.jpg


Hawaiian Picta
raoxm1.jpg
 
Last edited:
Usually they can be obtained through hawaiian shipments or from hired collectors but they are never regularly sold. I've had them on special order for months still no luck :facepalm:.

Running an advertisment for a hawaiian collector would be a good idea but they are still rare to find for the collector themself.
 
I'm from Hawaii and I've seen them at my LFS. I think it was about $35 each. I'll probably pick up one for a 7.5 g I'm starting up. Not sure if I want a pair or not, they're a bit pricey.
 
I'm from Hawaii and I've seen them at my LFS. I think it was about $35 each. I'll probably pick up one for a 7.5 g I'm starting up. Not sure if I want a pair or not, they're a bit pricey.

Lucky!! they are a very rare sight!! I'd snag them if I were you just for that reason. You guys may get them in more in hawaii because they are native to you guys.

Does that LFS by chance be willing to ship live stock here in the USA?
 
Haha, yeah. Still cost a pretty penny though. Definitely getting at least one. I would help you guys out and ship one to you but I doubt it'll be economically viable. I also wouldn't trust myself with the shipping, haha.
 
Haha, yeah. Still cost a pretty penny though. Definitely getting at least one. I would help you guys out and ship one to you but I doubt it'll be economically viable. I also wouldn't trust myself with the shipping, haha.

Thats cheap for a harlequin! A Good price range is $300 for a pair of hawaiian ones! $35 per harly is alot cheaper than for any of the regular ones at my lfs..
 
I guess that's the shipping costs and such! Haha, I'll keep that in mind when I go take a look. I guess I could always go back and get another one anyways. Is pairing them difficult? For some reason, the store charges and extra $5 for a pair.
 
Also, have you tried feeding them linckia stars? It's the easiest to get around here (other than brittles) so I might try to throw it into the fuge of my 40 breeder and cut off legs, maybe rotate 3-4 or something. Or am I better off just tossing them in whole?
 
Feedings:

Chocolate chip: success
Red knobbed:success
Red fromia: no success
Red tile: no success
Red Linkia:Success
Asterina: success

(Summary: They do not go for fromia sp. starfish, atleast not frozen as I never fed a live star to my harlys except asterinas as of yet)

Hake: Yet to find out.. somebody told me to try feeding them Hake and posted pictures claiming theirs did. I doubt this but worth a try.

Linkicas are harder to keep alive and CC are better for the rotation method of feeding. Throwing in whole is just as expensive as frozen but the method they use to eat and capture there prey makes many aim torwards the frozen diet instead. :)

Oh and btw, the $300 for a pair is without shipping.. (unless there is a free shipping deal for a certain price or large quanity order)
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the little chart. Unfortunately (but for the better of the environment) we are not allowed to import any inverts, so we're limited to local species. I've seen maybe 3-4 types of stars, but no CCs. I'll probably just toss in a while linckia to avoid putting any more fish stuff in the freezer.

And dang! That's ridiculous. I should learn how to ship these little guys.
 
Harlequin tankmate checklist

I'll make a little checklist of all the inhabitants I had success and no success living with my harlequins.

Pom pom crab: Success
Fire Shrimp: Success
Peppermint Shrimp: Success(Often played tug-o-war with starfish.. Fire shrimp usually chased away :D)
Sailfin tang(4inch): Success(So far, Tang was small, wouldn't recommend at all.)
Ocellarus Clownfish; Success
Yellow Watchman gobySuccess
Green Pistol Shrimp: Success (never seen the pistol really out at all.)
Sexy Shrimp: Success
Yellow tang(2 inch): Success (Wouldn't recommend)
Green banded goby:Success
Red tip hermit crab: Success (Often played tug-o-war over starfish... usually I had to break them up)
Camel Shrimp: Success
Pencil Urchin: Success
Rock boring urchin: No success (1 inch urchin disappeared, suspected to have been attacked by my old harlequin shrimp)
Scooter Blenny: Success
Bangai Cardinal: Success
Mexican turbo snail:Success
Turbo Snail:Success
Netrite Snail:Success
Nassarius Snail:Success
Bumblebee Snail: Success
Micro Brittle:Success
Flame Angel: Success(Sadly lost in a few days after getting it.. can't say how accurately safe it is)
Tailbot Damsel: No success (Actually picked up my harlequin by the claws and took it around a few laps in the tank.. eventually dropped it, no harm done, never introduce harlequin shrimp with any damsels)
Yellow-tip Hermit Crab: Success (Often played tug-o-war with harlequins... Which ended up me having to break up)
Electric blue knuckle Hermit Crab: Success
Asterina Starfish: No Success (Used for feeder.. but some lived in the tank for awhile inbetween feedings so I guess I'd include them...)


And the biggest predator I had in all my tanks which is the reason of all my harlequin's deaths is *Drum roll* POWERHEADS AND FILTER INTAKES Everything must be screened off for these guys. In my 10 gal, I have a Whisper filter carterage and I covered the intake of my Penquin bio-wheel 100 with it.
 
I managed to catch a video of my harlequin shrimp going for some frozen starfish. (Just click on the image to view the video)

Notice how the female is pink and the male is blue? Thats because the female is a Picta, and the male is an Elegans. They pair and travel peacefully but sometimes seperate to one side of the tank. Had them for 2 months and they never bred. They don't always agree on what to do or where to go so sometimes they push or walk over each other around 2:20. At 4:00 you can notice the female picta cleaning her left eye. at 5:10 they get scared and begin to panick as I atempt to feed them. This is normal behavior, I'm just begining to hand feed them which they are not used to. I'm feeding them a frozen starfish leg so consiture this as proof for those disbelievers in frozen diets. At 7:10 the male elegans, alone, decides what he wants to do. They take a few minutes to relize what is and what is not starfish. at 8:00 the male finally begins to drag his food back to their cave. The female is not interested at the momment and just sits there on the other side of the tank. Normally, pairs always travel with eachother no matter what, but in this case since she is a different sp. she has complete disregard of the male elegan's actions.

In this next video, The female finally decides to pitch in and help drag the starfish to "Her" cave.. Both were going in opposite directions.. their cave is simply around the bend and instead they are running into corners of the tank. The starfish leg should be around the same length as both shrimp standing on it. If one shrimp is finished eating, it will go hunting on it's own for more while the other eats. This means feeding time once again.

You will be needing bone cutters or the like as I struggle with a steak knife atempting to cut the leg off of the starfish.
 
Back
Top